Embark on a pub-hopping adventure through the bustling streets of New York City as we unveil the Best Pubs in the metropolis. From iconic haunts serving up classic pints to hidden gems with a modern twist, our guide captures the essence of NYC’s pub culture. Dive into the rich history and vibrant atmosphere as we navigate through neighborhoods, each boasting its unique pub scene. Whether you’re drawn to the coziness of a traditional Irish pub or the hip ambiance of a craft beer haven, our curated list ensures a taste of the city’s diverse pub landscape. Join us on a journey to discover the warmth, camaraderie, and unparalleled character of the Best Pubs in NYC.
McSorley’s Old Ale House is an old Irish tavern in NYC and has a respectable, storied feel right upon entry, with friendly bartender faces and sawdust covering the floor. This ale house, near Cooper Triangle, was established in 1854, making it one of the oldest bars in NYC. You can get any light or dark ale here and be in for a real treat.
Molly’s is an Irish pub near Gramercy Park with a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere. I like frequenting Molly’s for both food and drinks. I love their Irish whiskey, Irish coffee, and Irish stout just as much as their crispy fried calamari and homemade mozzarella sticks.
The Dead Rabbit is an eclectic, funky multi-story Irish pub in the Financial District. If you’re looking for an authentic Irish experience, The Dead Rabbit is the place to be. It features a great selection of whiskey and beer, but their cocktails are exceptionally impressive. I recommend ordering the Fine & Dandy or the Killer Queen.
Donavan’s, near the Doughboy Plaza in Sunnyside Gardens, is a pub with tasty types of beer and even tastier food. The best things to order here are the cheeseburger and Shepherd’s pie. You can’t go wrong with either of these menu items, especially with a cold Guinness to wash them down.
If you’re wondering where to get a drink with a more relaxed vibe, Swift Hibernian Lounge could easily become your next favorite spot. Located in NoHo near NYU, this Irish bar is known for its varied selection of craft beers. Whenever I go, I find a new favorite ale, lager, or IPA.
If you love Celtic music, Paddy Reilly’s Music Bar near Bellevue South Park is the place to be! I love going during happy hour to get excellent deals on Guinness, Bud Light, mixed drinks, and even wine. Plus, there’s always a buzzing crowd that’s fun and energizing to be around.
Peter McManus Cafe is a casual, straightforward Irish bar established in 1936. I appreciate the classic feel of the design, atmosphere, food, and drinks, especially in the middle of a more modern area such as Chelsea. I recommend ordering beer or your favorite beverage but coming hungry enough to down their delicious, award-winning cheeseburger.
An Beal Bocht Café, located in Kingsbridge near Gaelic Park, is an artsy Irish restaurant and pub. They have agreeable whiskey and cocktail lists with enough to choose from but not so much as to overwhelm me. And in addition to their good drinks, they also offer live performances of music, theater, poetry, and comedy, which I absolutely love!
The Landmark Tavern is another well-established, reputable Irish pub that opened in 1868. Located in Midtown near DeWitt Clinton Park, this bar is known for serving delicious classic pub fare in a cozy, friendly environment and playing traditional Irish tunes in the background.
If you like the idea of a particularly cozy pub, O’Hanlon’s should immediately go on your list. This local East Village pub has a laid-back, all-is-welcome feeling, and the pool tables and darts make it even more fun to visit with a group of friends.
Paddy Maguire’s Ale House, near the New York Comedy Club, is one of the most fun places to get drinks in NYC because it is not overly popular and crowded but has just the right vibes. I like how intricately it’s decorated with lights and other colorful decorations that bring a smile to my face. I recommend anything here because their prices are good for the budget.
Connolly’s is an amazing Irish-American pub chain, and the Midtown Manhattan location is the right one to go to if you’re hoping for a particularly buzzing atmosphere. You can dress accordingly or look however you want and expect the friendliest service as if it were a smaller, more intimate pub. However, you get the spaciousness of a larger establishment, which I sometimes appreciate.
Not so far from Connolly’s in the Times Square area is Sean’s Bar & Kitchen, a homey bar with a warm, almost irresistible charm. The Irish classics like Shepherd’s Pie and Irish stew are the best options to get here, along with Guinness or your favorite classic mixed drink.
Why should you trust us?
We use our own local experience and contacts in the city to know which places to include in our lists. We also researched the web and read 6 reputable blogs and websites, including tripadvisor.com, modernluxurymedia.com, timeout.com, foodrepublic.com, gayot.com and cntraveler.com. So that you can be sure you’re receiving the best of the best. We compiled all the results in one spot and ranked them according to how frequently they were referenced.