in ,

Most Popular Tiki Bars in the NYC Area

Tiki bars are one of the best places to escape reality and head to a tropical paradise, even if it’s just for a few hours. The best tiki bars in NYC feature fantastic music, delicious cocktails and food, and a fun and laid-back atmosphere.

person holding tiki cocktail at NYC tiki bars

I created this list after exploring as many tiki bars as possible in NYC. Please keep reading to take advantage of my hard research so you can escape to a tropical paradise this weekend.


Otto’s Shrunken Head

538 E 14th St, New York, NY 10009
Phone: (212) 228-2240
Visit Website

Otto’s Shrunken Head has perhaps the best name of any tiki bar in NYC. This fun and quirky bar features a tiki-inspired atmosphere, with tiki masks, tropical drinks, a colorful mural on the wall, and more.

The music here is always exciting and upbeat, with a great selection of beers on tap and tiki-inspired cocktails. There is often live music, so check out their website for the lineup.


The Polynesian

400 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 254-3000
Visit Website

The Polynesian is another one of the best tiki bars in NYC, with an engaging and lively atmosphere perfect for lounging around with friends.

Thanks to its great music and a fantastic selection of tropical cocktails and beers on tap, this tiki bar is always buzzing with people.

The decor will transport you to an island resort no matter what the weather is outside.


Zombie Hut

273 Smith St #4739, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Phone: (718) 875-3433
Visit Website

Zombie Hut looks like something straight out of a remote pacific island. With tiki masks, tiki torches, surfboards, and more, this tiki bar provides a genuinely immersive tiki experience.

There are some tremendous island-inspired drinks and food, and the prices are reasonable. There are also board games that you can play with your friends.


Jade Island

2845 Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314
Phone: (718) 761-8080
Visit Website

Jade Island combines island vibes and delicious Chinese food missing from your life. This bar is in a shopping center that is well known for its delicious Chinese food.

Come for the food and stay for the exotic drinks.


Broken Shaker at Freehand New York

23 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10010
Phone: (212) 475-1920
Visit Website

The Broken Shaker at Freehand New York is not the first tiki bar to go by this name. It was inspired by the original that you can still visit in Miami.

This tiki bar is in the lobby of Freehand New York, which used to be a hotel. It has a very relaxed atmosphere, with a tiki bar that serves up tiki-inspired cocktails and food.

The happy hour is one of the best in the city, and you will want to order several of the cocktails.


Dromedary Urban Tiki Bar

266 Irving Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237
Phone: (347) 715-4255
Visit Website

Dromedary Urban Tiki Bar is one of the lesser-known tiki bars in NYC. But that doesn’t mean it’s not one of the best tiki bars in NYC.

This bar is in a former tavern, which gives it a unique ambiance. The fantastic board games and the innovative pub fare are the highlights of coming here.

It is the perfect combination that will have you coming back week after week.


Fort Defiance

347 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Phone: (347) 457-5082
Visit Website

Fort Defiance is a tiki bar that embodies the neighborhood’s past with tiki masks and nautical decor. The tiki drinks are excellent and refreshing, and the tiki bar stays open later than most to accommodate your tiki partying needs.

I highly recommend brunch. You can get killer huevos rancheros and one of the best bloody marys in the city.


GITANO Garden of Love

125 Carder Rd, New York, NY 10004
Visit Website

GITANO Garden of Love is an intimate tiki bar located in Brooklyn. It’s a twist on the traditional tiki bar. It combines the tiki vibes with a distinct Tulum-inspired jungle setting.

The seasonal menu changes frequently, and the tiki-inspired cocktails are sure to please any tiki lover. Whether you’re looking for a place to lounge around or throw your next party, check out GITANO Garden of Love.


Super Power

722 Nostrand Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11216
Phone: (718) 484-0020
Visit Website

Super Power is one of the best tiki bars in NYC if you’re looking for a place to dance. The tiki drinks are strong, with some tiki cocktails you can’t find anywhere else.

The bar is also known for its tiki-inspired happy hour specials, so come here if you’re looking for a tiki night out. Make sure you eat before coming here because the bar only serves a few snacks.


Shaka Shaka Tiki

64 6th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: (347) 689-3184
Visit Website

Shaka Shaka Tiki is one of the tiniest tiki bars in NYC, but it’s also one of the most beloved tiki bars around. The tiki drinks are strong, and the bartenders serve up some of the best-frozen drinks in NYC.

I also highly recommend the juice cocktails, which are made fresh. Come for the drinks but stay for the music.


Sunken Harbor Club

372 Fulton St 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Phone: (347) 689-3677
Visit Website

Sunken Harbor Club is a tiki bar and lounge located in Brooklyn. The tiki drinks are strong, but the food makes this tiki bar stand out. Unlike many other tiki bars on this list, Sunken Harbor Club is a speakeasy.

Once you step into the bar, you are transported underwater to a nautical theme that looks like something from 20,000 leagues under the seas.


Tiki Chick

517 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Visit Website

Tiki Chick is a tiki bar in New York City inspired by tiki bars in the Caribbean. The tiki drinks are served in tiki mugs and tiki totems, which adds to the tropical energy.

Their specialty cocktail menu also includes a wide range of Pina Coladas and Mai Tais. The food here is incredible. The hot honey chicken and spam sandwiches will take your experience to the next level.


Zig Zag

382 Marcus Garvey Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11221
Phone: (718) 484-4341
Visit Website

Zig Zag is one of the premier tiki bars in NYC. If you are even in Brooklyn, you have to stop and check out this small bar.

Although the space is small, the bartenders and friendly regulars create a fun atmosphere. They also play excellent music, so it’s the perfect bar to dance the night away.


MAI TAIS TIKI BAR & KITCHEN

1087 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221
Visit Website

What’s the perfect pairing for a frozen pina colada or mai tai? Dumplings! MAI TAIS TIKI BAR & KITCHEN serves up some of the best-frozen cocktail drinks in Brooklyn and some incredible dumplings.

The interior has a distinct Hawaiian vibe with many throwback retro decorations from the 70s and 80s. The happy hour is one the best in the city, so don’t miss it.


Rockaway Tiki Bar

6720 Rockaway Beach Blvd, Queens, NY 11692
Phone: (347) 619-9369
Visit Website

Rockaway tiki bar is the tiki bar on the beach! It’s a tiki bar that takes tiki bars to the next level. The inside resembles a beachfront bar and a small artificial beach out front.

On warm summer days, you can lay out and catch a tan. I highly recommend the poke bowl and the dumplings. I promise you they are worth the wait. If you want something more traditional, the sliders are also delicious.


Pokito

155 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Phone: (917) 909-1542
Visit Website

Pokito takes a unique approach to the classic tiki bar. This bar combines Asian and Latin flavors and decor to create a unique venue with one of NYC’s most exciting menus.

I highly recommend you visit during happy hour so you can sample a variety of menu items. The yuca dishes and empanadas are incredible.


Holiday Cocktail Lounge

75 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003
Phone: (212) 777-9637
Visit Website

Who says you can’t teach an old dog new tricks? The Holiday Cocktail lounge was one of the classic dive bars in NYC.

It is now one of the swankiest new bars in NYC, with tasty food and larger-than-life drinks.


Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for the best tiki bars in NYC, look no further than these top picks. From fun, tiki-inspired cocktails and tiki-themed decor to dancing and great food, they have everything!

These tiki bars have what you need for the perfect tiki night out. Whether you’re looking to lounge around or party all night, these tiki bars have you covered.

Did we miss any tiki bars in NYC? Let us know in the comments below.


Best Tiki Bars in NYC

  1. Otto’s Shrunken Head
  2. The Polynesian
  3. Zombie Hut
  4. Jade Island
  5. Broken Shaker at Freehand New York
  6. Dromedary Urban Tiki Bar
  7. Fort Defiance
  8. GITANO Garden of Love
  9. Super Power
  10. Shaka Shaka Tiki
  11. Sunken Harbor Club
  12. Tiki Chick
  13. Zig Zag
  14. MAI TAIS TIKI BAR & KITCHEN
  15. Rockaway Tiki Bar
  16. Pokito
  17. Holiday Cocktail Lounge

Written by Rocco

Rocco is a Florida State University alumnus with years of bartending and hospitality experience. From slinging hundreds of vodka sodas a night in jam-packed college bars to serving carefully crafted cocktails in upscale restaurants, there’s not much he hasn’t done behind a bar. Now, Rocco shares his knowledge and passion for all things alcohol-related here on My Bartender for bibulous readers everywhere to enjoy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings

Christmas punch recipes serving for christmas and winter holiday party

15 Christmas Punch Recipes for Your Holiday Party

sipping glass of cocktail in NYC martini bars

The Hottest Martini Bars NYC Has to Offer