Strawberry Jam Paper Plane is one of those cocktails that feels both familiar and a little unexpected in the best way. The first time I made it, I already liked the classic Paper Plane, but the addition of strawberry jam made it stand out right away.

This version keeps the equal-parts structure, so it stays balanced and easy to mix. The jam adds a soft fruit sweetness that blends smoothly with the citrus and bitters. I like how it feels slightly richer while still finishing clean. It’s a great choice for evenings when you want something simple, a little creative, and easy to enjoy.

Why You’ll Love This

This cocktail takes a modern classic and adds a fresh fruit twist that makes it even more enjoyable.

Balanced mix of sweet, bitter, and citrus flavors
Strawberry jam adds a soft fruity layer
Equal parts recipe makes it easy to remember
Great for both casual and more refined settings
Smooth and well-rounded flavor profile
Looks impressive with minimal effort

Once you try it, you will see how the jam adds just enough sweetness without overpowering the drink.

Ingredients

This recipe sticks close to the original Paper Plane structure, but adds strawberry jam for a unique twist. Each ingredient plays an important role in the balance.

0.75 oz bourbon
0.75 oz Aperol
0.75 oz Amaro Nonino
0.75 oz lemon juice
0.25 oz strawberry jam about 1 bar spoon
3 dashes bitters
Strawberry for garnish

Bourbon provides a warm and smooth base. Aperol adds a light bitterness with a hint of citrus, while Amaro Nonino brings depth and complexity.

Suggested Liquor Brands and Substitutions

Choosing quality spirits can make a difference, especially in a balanced cocktail like this.

Buffalo Trace Bourbon
Smooth and slightly sweet, great for mixing
Maker’s Mark
Soft and rounded with a bit of warmth
Aperol
Classic choice for its bright and slightly bitter profile
Amaro Nonino
Essential for the traditional Paper Plane flavor
Substitute strawberry jam with raspberry jam
Adds a slightly sharper fruit note

These options help you maintain balance while allowing for small adjustments in flavor.

Equipment and Glassware

You only need a few basic tools to make this cocktail, which makes it easy to prepare at home.

A coupe glass works best for a clean presentation, but a rocks glass with a large ice cube is also a great option.

How to Make It

This cocktail comes together quickly, but the key is properly mixing the jam so it blends smoothly.

Add strawberry jam and lemon juice to a shaker and stir or give a short dry shake to loosen the jam
Add bourbon Aperol Amaro Nonino bitters and ice
Shake hard until well chilled about 10 to 15 seconds
Double strain into a chilled coupe or over a large ice cube in a rocks glass
Garnish with a slit strawberry on the rim

Once it is poured, take a moment to enjoy the aroma before your first sip.

Pro Tips

A few small techniques can make a big difference in how this cocktail turns out.

Loosen the jam first so it mixes evenly
Always double strain to remove pulp and keep the texture smooth
Use fresh lemon juice for the best balance
Shake well to fully integrate all ingredients
Chill your glass before serving
Measure carefully since this is an equal parts cocktail
Adjust jam slightly if you want more fruit flavor

Once you get the technique right, it becomes easy to repeat.

Variations

This cocktail is flexible enough to allow for a few creative changes.

Use raspberry or blackberry jam for a different fruit profile
Swap bourbon for rye for a spicier version
Add a splash of sparkling wine for a lighter finish
Use orange bitters instead of standard bitters
Make it alcohol-free with citrus juice and a non-alcoholic aperitif

These variations let you keep the base idea while exploring new flavors.

When to Serve and Pairings

This drink works well in both casual and more refined settings. It feels balanced enough for sipping but still fun and approachable.

I like serving this when I want something that feels a bit elevated without being complicated. It is great for small gatherings or evening drinks.

Pair it with:

Light appetizers
Cheese boards
Grilled chicken or pork
Fruit-based desserts
Dark chocolate treats

The mix of citrus and sweetness pairs well with both savory and sweet foods.

Storage and Serving Notes

This cocktail is best made fresh because of the citrus and jam.

You can pre-measure the spirits, but it is best to mix everything just before serving to keep the flavors bright.

Always strain well to ensure a smooth texture.

FAQs

What is a Paper Plane cocktail
It is a modern cocktail made with equal parts bourbon Aperol Amaro Nonino and lemon juice.

Does the jam make it too sweet
No, it adds a gentle sweetness that balances the bitterness and citrus.

Can I skip the bitters
You can, but they add depth to the overall flavor.

More Cocktails to Try

If you enjoyed this Strawberry Jam Paper Plane, here are a few more cocktails with a similar balanced style: