The Top 50 Bourbons Brands Ranked

Bourbon isn’t just booming—it’s become a full-blown obsession. With new bottles hitting shelves every month and die-hard fans swapping tips like baseball cards, we at MyBartender knew it was time to put together our definitive Top 50 list. How’d we rank them? We used a double-barreled approach: quality, as judged by seasoned whiskey drinkers and critics, and popularity, straight from the bourbon-loving voices in our community.

We polled our readers—hundreds of you shouted out favorites from Buffalo Trace to Blanton’s—then lined those picks up against expert reviews from bourbon influencers, tasting panels, and respected sources like Breaking Bourbon and Fred Minnick. The result is a list that balances smooth, small-batch craft with beloved classics and collector-worthy hype bottles.

Will everyone agree? Not a chance. Bourbon rankings are guaranteed to stir up some heat. Some will cheer seeing Pappy crack the top 10, others might raise an eyebrow at Jim Beam’s placement—but that’s what makes this fun. This list is as much yours as it is ours, shaped by sippers, collectors, and bartenders alike. So pour yourself a finger (or two), scroll on, and find out where your go-to bottle landed—or what you’ll be trying next.

#50 – Hillrock

Hillrock Estate Distillery brings a luxurious, farm-to-glass approach to bourbon from the Hudson Valley in New York. Founded by Jeffrey Baker and with help from the late Master Distiller Dave Pickerell, Hillrock was one of the first U.S. distilleries to fully control every step of the process—growing its own grain, malting on-site, and aging in specially selected barrels. Their Solera Aged Bourbon is the star, blending older stocks in a continuous aging system for deep, layered flavor with hints of dried fruit, toffee, and spice. Hillrock earns its place for craftsmanship, innovation, and redefining what estate bourbon can be.

#49 – Benchmark

Benchmark is a value bourbon from Buffalo Trace that offers surprising quality for its low price point. Originally created by Seagram’s and later acquired by Sazerac, Benchmark is named to honor the McAfee brothers, early American explorers who surveyed the Kentucky land where the distillery now stands. The standard Old No. 8 is an easy sipper, while newer expressions like Top Floor, Small Batch, and Full Proof offer stepped-up flavor and complexity. Benchmark makes our list for being an accessible, budget-friendly bourbon that still carries the craftsmanship and credibility of one of the best distilleries in the business.

#48 – Jim Beam

Jim Beam’s story starts in 1795 with Jacob Beam, who sold his first barrel in Kentucky, laying the foundation for America’s best-selling bourbon. Renamed for James B. “Jim” Beam in 1933, the brand rebuilt post-Prohibition in Clermont, Kentucky, under the Beam family’s seven-generation watch, now part of Suntory’s portfolio since 2014. Known for its 51% corn mash bill, key bottles include the White Label (80 proof, affordable and ubiquitous), Black Label (86 proof, richer oak), and Single Barrel (108 proof, a quality leap). Jim Beam earns its spot for its historical heft and surprising depth—enthusiasts like its higher-end releases, while influencers (e.g., Bourbon Junkies) respect its role as a gateway bourbon. It’s not the flashiest, but its consistency, global reach, and legacy of quality craftsmanship make it a must-include, bridging mass appeal with solid sipping cred.

#47 – Noah’s Mill

Noah’s Mill is a small batch bourbon from Willett that delivers big flavor in a compact, high-proof package. Bottled at 114.3 proof, it balances power and complexity with notes of roasted nuts, vanilla, toffee, and spice. While it no longer carries an age statement, earlier versions were aged up to 15 years, and today’s releases still reflect that depth. It’s well-regarded for sipping neat and offers richness without overwhelming heat. Noah’s Mill earns its spot for providing a bold, well-crafted experience that appeals to serious bourbon drinkers looking for something off the beaten path.

#46 – Henry McKenna

Henry McKenna is best known for its 10-Year Bottled-in-Bond bourbon, one of the few age-stated, single-barrel bottled-in-bond offerings available. Made by Heaven Hill, it gained major attention after winning Best in Show Whiskey at the 2019 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. With deep notes of caramel, oak, and spice, each barrel offers slight variation while maintaining consistent quality. Its long aging and strong proof make it a favorite for seasoned bourbon fans. Henry McKenna earns a place on our list for offering rare specs—10 years, single barrel, bottled-in-bond—all in one exceptional bottle.

#45 – Jack Daniel’s

While often associated with Tennessee whiskey, Jack Daniel’s earns a spot on this bourbon list for its recent push into the straight bourbon category with releases like Bonded and Triple Mash. These expressions meet all the requirements for bourbon and showcase the brand’s ability to craft rich, flavorful whiskey beyond the classic Old No. 7. Jack Daniel’s has unmatched global recognition, and its newer bottled-in-bond lineup offers bolder, more complex versions of what fans love. It makes our list for blending iconic status with legitimate bourbon credibility, especially with its recent award-winning expressions.

#44 – Garrison Brothers

Garrison Brothers is Texas’s first legal bourbon distillery and a pioneer in the craft whiskey scene. Based in Hye, Texas, it embraces the state’s intense climate to accelerate aging, producing bold, oaky bourbon with a deep, rich flavor. Founded in 2006, the distillery uses organic corn, wheat, and barley, with everything done on-site—from mashing to bottling. Signature releases like Small Batch and Cowboy Bourbon are full-bodied and high-proof, often featuring notes of dark fruit, leather, and spice. Garrison Brothers earns a place on our list for its trailblazing spirit, big Texas character, and commitment to quality craft bourbon.

#43 – Kentucky Owl

Kentucky Owl is a high-end bourbon brand known for its bold, limited-edition releases and cult-like following. Originally founded in the late 1800s and revived in 2014 by Dixon Dedman, the brand quickly made waves with rich, high-proof blends that captured the attention of collectors. Now owned by Stoli Group, Kentucky Owl continues to release rare batches under its Bourbon and Rye lines, often featuring complex layers of caramel, spice, and oak. Prices are steep, but so is the quality. It earns a spot on our list for bringing luxury appeal and standout flavor to modern bourbon.

#42 – Smooth Ambler

Smooth Ambler, based in West Virginia, blends Appalachian spirit with bourbon craft. Originally gaining fame for its Old Scout line—sourced high-rye MGP bourbon—Smooth Ambler has since expanded into making its own whiskey while continuing to blend and bottle sourced barrels. The brand embraces transparency, clearly labeling what’s distilled in-house versus sourced. Old Scout remains a fan favorite for its bold spice and strong proof, while their Contradiction series mixes sourced and house-made bourbon. Smooth Ambler earns a spot on our list for its honesty, quality blending, and role in introducing many fans to MGP’s high-rye style.

#41 – Old Carter

Old Carter is a boutique bourbon brand known for crafting small, ultra-limited batches that cater to serious whiskey collectors. Founded by Mark and Sherri Carter, the couple behind the revival of Kentucky Owl, Old Carter focuses on hand-selecting and blending sourced barrels to create bold, high-proof expressions. Each release is numbered and unique, with rich layers of caramel, spice, and oak that often exceed expectations. With a cult-like following and prices to match, Old Carter earns its place on our list for delivering standout, premium bourbon that feels personal, rare, and expertly blended.

#40 – Frey Ranch

Frey Ranch is a true grain-to-glass operation based in Fallon, Nevada. Founded by Colby and Ashley Frey, the distillery grows all of its own grains on a fifth-generation family farm, making it one of the few truly estate-produced bourbons in the U.S. Their flagship Straight Bourbon is bottled at 90 proof and features a four-grain mash bill—corn, rye, wheat, and malted barley—for a well-balanced flavor with notes of vanilla, cinnamon, and toasted grain. Frey Ranch earns a place on our list for its transparency, quality, and dedication to hands-on farming and distilling from start to finish.

#39 – Balcones

Balcones brings bold Texas style to the world of bourbon. Based in Waco and founded in 2008, the distillery gained early attention for its creative, grain-forward whiskeys. Balcones Texas Pot Still Bourbon is made from blue corn and other regional grains, giving it a rich, nutty flavor with notes of roasted oak, spice, and dark fruit. The distillation is done in copper pot stills, resulting in a thick, flavorful spirit that stands out from traditional Kentucky bourbon. Balcones makes our list for offering a unique, craft-driven take on bourbon that proudly reflects its Texas roots.

#38 – Bardstown Bourbon Company

Bardstown Bourbon Company blends cutting-edge innovation with deep respect for tradition. Founded in 2014, it quickly became a major player by offering contract distilling for other brands while also developing its own impressive lineup. Its Fusion, Discovery, and Origin Series highlight blends of sourced and house-made bourbons with layered, complex flavor profiles. With a modern, transparent approach and a state-of-the-art facility, Bardstown is changing what a bourbon distillery can look and feel like. It makes our list for its rapid rise, commitment to quality, and role in shaping the future of American whiskey.

#37 – Town Branch

Town Branch is a Lexington, Kentucky distillery making a name with its rich, full-bodied bourbon and beautiful copper pot stills. Part of Alltech’s beverage division, it became one of the first new distilleries to open on the Kentucky Bourbon Trail in over a century. The bourbon is aged in new charred oak barrels and bottled at 90 proof, offering notes of toffee, oak, and sweet corn. Town Branch also produces rye, single malts, and finished bourbons, showing its willingness to experiment. It earns a spot on our list for bringing craft quality and hometown pride to Kentucky’s bourbon revival.

#36 – Redemption

Redemption bourbon is built on a high-rye mash bill that delivers bold spice and deep flavor, perfect for fans of a punchier pour. Originally launched to spotlight classic pre-Prohibition whiskey styles, Redemption sources its bourbon from MGP and focuses on blending for consistency and character. The standard bourbon is approachable and affordable, while the High Rye and Barrel Proof expressions offer more intensity. With its vintage-inspired design and straightforward focus on rye-forward profiles, Redemption stands out on the shelf. It earns a spot on our list for offering solid value, distinctive flavor, and wide appeal in a competitive category.

#35 – High West

High West is known for blending Western charm with whiskey innovation. Based in Park City, Utah, it became the state’s first legal distillery since Prohibition when it launched in 2006. While the brand is better known for rye, its bourbon offerings—like High West American Prairie Bourbon—deliver smooth, flavorful pours with high-rye spice and subtle sweetness. Many of their releases are blends of sourced whiskeys, carefully curated and aged. Limited editions like Bourye and A Midwinter Night’s Dram (a blend of bourbon and rye) further showcase High West’s creativity. It earns a place on our list for quality, storytelling, and style.

#34 – Remus

Remus bourbon is a tribute to George Remus, the “King of the Bootleggers,” and a bold celebration of Prohibition-era whiskey. Produced by MGP in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, the brand stands out for embracing its source rather than hiding it. The core Remus Straight Bourbon offers balanced flavor at a fair price, but the spotlight is on the annual Repeal Reserve series—limited releases that showcase well-aged, expertly blended high-rye bourbons. With rich notes of spice, oak, and caramel, Remus bottles appeal to history buffs and serious bourbon fans alike. It earns a spot on our list for combining strong storytelling with exceptional blending.

#33 – Rabbit Hole

Rabbit Hole is a modern Louisville distillery making waves with sleek design and bold flavor. Founded in 2012 by Kaveh Zamanian, the brand set out to challenge bourbon norms while respecting its roots. Rabbit Hole distills its own whiskey using unique mash bills and transparent aging. Offerings like Cavehill (four-grain bourbon), Heigold (high-rye), and Dareringer (finished in sherry casks) show the brand’s creative range. With a state-of-the-art facility and stylish branding, Rabbit Hole attracts a new generation of bourbon drinkers. It earns its spot for combining originality, quality, and a forward-thinking approach in a crowded market.

#32 – Old Elk

Old Elk blends craftsmanship and innovation with a unique flavor profile that sets it apart from traditional bourbons. Founded in Fort Collins, Colorado, the brand was developed with Master Distiller Greg Metze, formerly of MGP, who created a custom mash bill with a high malted barley content. This gives Old Elk a smooth, creamy texture and softer spice compared to typical high-rye bourbons. Core offerings include the flagship Straight Bourbon, Wheated Bourbon, and Double Wheat. Old Elk earns its place on the list for quality blending, creative mash bills, and proving that standout bourbon can come from outside Kentucky.

#31 – Penelope

Penelope is a newer bourbon brand that has quickly made waves with its smooth blends and modern approach. Launched in 2018 and named after the founder’s daughter, the brand uses MGP-sourced bourbon and blends four different mash bills to create a balanced and approachable flavor. Offerings like the Four Grain, Barrel Strength, and Architect series appeal to both newcomers and seasoned drinkers with layers of vanilla, fruit, and spice. Limited releases and wine-cask finishes keep things interesting. Penelope earns its place for delivering clean, crowd-pleasing bourbon with thoughtful blending and a fresh, growing reputation.

#30 – Kings County

Kings County is a craft distillery that brings Brooklyn attitude to Kentucky tradition. Founded in 2010, it was one of the first New York-based distilleries to produce bourbon since Prohibition. Despite its small size, Kings County has earned big respect for its handmade, pot-distilled bourbon made with New York corn and barley. Known for its minimalist labels and small bottle sizes, the brand focuses on quality and innovation. Its Straight Bourbon and Bottled-in-Bond expressions are rich, grain-forward, and full of character. Kings County earns a spot for showing that great bourbon can come from outside Kentucky—with style and substance.

#29 – Jefferson’s

Jefferson’s is known for its creative approach to bourbon, blending tradition with experimentation. Founded in 1997 by Trey Zoeller and his father, the brand sources and blends barrels to create unique flavor profiles. Its most famous release, Jefferson’s Ocean, is aged at sea, where the motion and salty air are said to influence the whiskey’s character. Other expressions like Reserve, Very Old, and Tropics Finished continue the brand’s innovative streak. Jefferson’s makes our list for keeping bourbon fresh and exciting while still honoring the core elements that make it great.

#28 – Willett

Willett is a family-owned distillery with deep Kentucky roots and a cult following among bourbon lovers. Established in 1936, the brand gained new momentum in recent years with the revival of in-house distilling and a lineup that ranges from approachable to ultra-rare. The Willett Pot Still Reserve is instantly recognizable, while their Family Estate bottlings—often single barrel and barrel proof—are some of the most sought-after pours on the market. With bold, complex flavors and strong collector appeal, Willett earns its spot for delivering standout whiskey with small-batch charm and serious pedigree.

#27 – Evan Williams

Evan Williams is one of the best-selling bourbons in the world, offering solid quality at a price that’s hard to beat. Produced by Heaven Hill, it’s named after one of Kentucky’s earliest distillers. The Black Label is a staple in bars and homes alike, while the Bottled-in-Bond White Label is a favorite among budget-conscious bourbon fans for its 100-proof strength and classic flavor. With rich notes of oak, caramel, and spice, Evan Williams proves that good bourbon doesn’t have to be expensive. It earns its place on our list for dependability, value, and everyday appeal.

#26 – Barrell Craft Spirits

Barrell Craft Spirits is known for pushing the boundaries of blending and innovation in bourbon. Founded in 2013, the company sources high-quality barrels from across the U.S. and expertly blends them into unique, often high-proof releases. Each batch of Barrell Bourbon is different, offering bold flavors like dark fruit, spice, and toasted oak. Limited editions like the Gray Label and Gold Label series highlight their premium approach. Barrell made our list for elevating sourced bourbon through expert blending and transparency, consistently creating award-winning, adventurous releases that appeal to serious collectors and flavor seekers alike.

#25 – Smoke Wagon

Smoke Wagon brings Nevada flair to the bourbon world, blending high-quality MGP-sourced whiskey with unique character and sleek packaging. Based in Las Vegas and launched in 2016, the brand quickly gained a cult following thanks to its bold, spicy flavor and unfiltered bottlings. Offerings like the Small Batch and Uncut Unfiltered are rich, high-proof pours with deep caramel, pepper, and oak notes. Limited runs and engraved bottles add collector appeal. Smoke Wagon earns its place on our list for proving that blending skill and brand personality can turn sourced bourbon into something truly distinctive and sought-after.

#24 – Old Grand-Dad

Old Grand-Dad is a high-rye bourbon with a bold, spicy character and a long history. Created in the late 1800s by Basil Hayden’s grandson, the brand has stayed true to its fiery profile, appealing to those who like their bourbon with a kick. The Bottled-in-Bond and 114-proof versions are especially popular, offering strong flavor at a budget-friendly price. It’s a favorite among bartenders for its versatility in cocktails and fans for its punchy, no-nonsense taste. Old Grand-Dad earns its spot for being a reliable, full-flavored bourbon that proves you don’t need deep pockets to drink well.

#23 – Heaven Hill

Heaven Hill is one of the largest and most respected bourbon producers in Kentucky, with a legacy dating back to 1935. As a family-owned distillery, it’s behind a wide range of beloved brands, but its namesake line showcases solid craftsmanship and tradition. The Heaven Hill Bottled-in-Bond 7-Year is especially praised for its depth, value, and classic flavor profile. With notes of oak, spice, and vanilla, it appeals to bourbon fans who appreciate structure and balance. It earns a place on our list for delivering age, quality, and affordability in a no-frills bottle that consistently overdelivers.

#22 – Russell’s Reserve

Russell’s Reserve is a tribute to Jimmy and Eddie Russell, the father-son Master Distiller duo behind Wild Turkey. Known for its balance of tradition and refinement, the brand offers standout bottles like the 10-Year Small Batch and Single Barrel, both showcasing rich caramel, vanilla, and spice. Limited releases, including the Russell’s Reserve 13-Year, have earned critical praise and cult status. It’s aged longer than standard Wild Turkey expressions and crafted with care, making it a favorite among enthusiasts. Russell’s Reserve makes our list for combining heritage, craftsmanship, and excellent value across a high-quality, age-stated lineup.

#21 – New Riff

New Riff is one of the most exciting young distilleries in bourbon today. Founded in 2014 in Newport, Kentucky, this independently owned distillery has quickly earned respect for doing things the right way from the start. Every bottle is bottled-in-bond, non-chill filtered, and made with a high-rye mash bill that delivers bold, spicy flavor with a touch of sweetness.

New Riff’s standard bourbon is aged at least four years, while their Single Barrel program and experimental limited releases—like malted rye or heirloom grain mash bills—keep bourbon fans curious and engaged. Transparency, quality, and innovation drive the brand’s reputation. New Riff made our list for proving that age isn’t everything—when a distillery focuses on integrity and flavor, great bourbon can come from a new name.

#20 – E.H. Taylor

E.H. Taylor is a tribute to one of bourbon’s founding fathers—Colonel Edmund Haynes Taylor Jr., a 19th-century pioneer who helped modernize the industry through innovations in aging, bottling, and quality control. Produced at Buffalo Trace, the brand celebrates his legacy with a lineup of bottled-in-bond and limited-edition expressions that reflect classic bourbon character and attention to detail.

The flagship Small Batch Bottled-in-Bond bourbon is a favorite for its balance of sweetness, spice, and oak, while rare releases like Single Barrel, Straight Rye, and the coveted Four Grain and Warehouse C Tornado Surviving bottles have fueled a strong collector’s market. E.H. Taylor earned its place on this list for honoring bourbon’s history while consistently delivering complex, highly rated pours that live up to the legacy of its namesake.

#19 – Larceny

Larceny is a wheated bourbon that offers smoothness, sweetness, and solid value, all under the respected Heaven Hill banner. It traces its roots back to John E. Fitzgerald, a treasury agent with a reputation for sneaking sips from the best barrels—earning him a legendary (and slightly shady) place in bourbon lore. The brand plays off this story, highlighting the “larceny” of great taste.

Larceny’s regular Small Batch expression is soft and mellow, thanks to the use of wheat instead of rye in the mash bill. But it’s the Barrel Proof editions that have really turned heads, earning top awards and recognition for their rich, bold profiles at cask strength. Larceny makes our list because it delivers both easy-drinking options and high-proof excitement, all with a unique backstory and consistent Heaven Hill craftsmanship.

#18 – 1792

1792 bourbon is bold, flavorful, and often overlooked—which makes it one of the best hidden gems in Kentucky. Named after the year Kentucky became a state, it’s distilled at Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, one of the oldest active distilleries in the region. Owned by Sazerac (the same parent company as Buffalo Trace), 1792 is known for its high-rye mash bill that gives it a spicy, robust character.

The flagship Small Batch is a great value, but the brand shines in its special releases like Full Proof, Bottled-in-Bond, and Single Barrel—each one offering rich oak, caramel, and baking spice notes. Full Proof even won World’s Best Bourbon at the 2020 World Whiskies Awards. 1792 made our list because it consistently overdelivers for the price and proves that exceptional bourbon doesn’t need hype to be world-class.

---

#17 – Basil Hayden

Basil Hayden is known for its light, approachable style and elegant packaging, making it a popular entry point for new bourbon drinkers. Created in 1992 as part of Jim Beam’s Small Batch Collection, it honors Meredith Basil Hayden Sr., a distiller who used a high-rye mash bill back in the late 1700s. That rye-forward recipe still defines the brand today, giving Basil Hayden a gentle spice and dryness that sets it apart.

At 80 proof, the original bourbon is lower in alcohol than many on this list, but it’s intentionally crafted for easy sipping. Recent releases like Toast, Dark Rye, and Subtle Smoke show the brand’s growing ambition and willingness to experiment. Basil Hayden earns a spot on our list for bridging the gap between beginner-friendly and refined—delivering a smooth, stylish bourbon that holds its own in a crowd of bolder pours.

#16 – Angel’s Envy

Angel’s Envy stands out in the bourbon world for its innovative approach to finishing. Founded by Lincoln Henderson, a former Master Distiller at Brown-Forman, and later run by his son Wes, the brand set itself apart by aging its bourbon in port wine barrels after the initial maturation. This finishing process adds a layer of sweetness and complexity that makes Angel’s Envy instantly recognizable.

Their flagship Port Finished Bourbon is smooth and approachable, with notes of vanilla, ripe fruit, and a hint of red wine. Limited releases like the Cask Strength version and rye whiskey finished in Caribbean rum casks have added to its reputation. Angel’s Envy earned a place on our list for pushing boundaries without losing bourbon’s core character—making it a favorite for those who enjoy a modern twist on tradition.

#15 – Michter’s

Michter’s has one of the oldest names in American whiskey, dating back to 1753 in Pennsylvania, but the modern brand was revived in Kentucky with a focus on small batch excellence and attention to detail. Today, Michter’s is known for producing high-quality bourbons at its Shively distillery in Louisville and its Fort Nelson location, with plans for full in-house grain-to-bottle production in the future.

The lineup includes the popular US*1 Small Batch Bourbon, along with more exclusive offerings like the 10-Year Single Barrel and limited-release Celebration Sour Mash. Michter’s uses heat-cycled aging warehouses and a custom filtration process to deliver rich, smooth, and balanced flavor profiles. It earned its place on this list for turning a revived legacy into a modern standard of premium bourbon, consistently impressing both casual sippers and seasoned connoisseurs.

#14 – George T. Stagg

George T. Stagg is a titan in the bourbon world, known for high-proof, age-stated releases that push the limits of flavor and intensity. Part of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, this limited-release bourbon is typically aged 15 to 17 years and bottled uncut and unfiltered, often reaching well over 120 proof. Named after one of the most influential figures in bourbon history, the brand honors Stagg’s role in shaping what is now the Buffalo Trace Distillery.

Each fall release becomes a major event for collectors and enthusiasts, with bottles selling out instantly and commanding high resale prices. Rich with deep caramel, dark fruit, leather, and spice, George T. Stagg is a bold and unforgettable pour. It earns a top spot on our list for its legendary status, rarity, and consistent reputation as one of the most powerful and rewarding bourbons available.

#13 – Booker’s

Booker’s is a powerhouse of uncut, unfiltered bourbon that helped define the premium small batch category. Created by legendary Master Distiller Booker Noe in the late 1980s, this Jim Beam brand was one of the first to offer bourbon straight from the barrel, giving drinkers a bold and authentic experience. Each batch is released at barrel strength, usually between 120–130 proof, and aged around six to eight years.

Booker’s is known for its rich flavor profile—think vanilla, oak, spice, and a long, warm finish. Each release is named with a story tied to Booker Noe’s life, giving it a personal touch that adds to its cult following. It made our list for setting the standard in barrel-proof bourbon and for staying true to its roots in quality, strength, and character.

#12 – Old Forester

Old Forester holds a special place in bourbon history—it was the first bourbon to be sold in sealed bottles, starting in 1870. Founded by George Garvin Brown in Louisville, Kentucky, the brand emphasized quality and consistency in an era when whiskey was often adulterated. Today, it’s still produced by Brown-Forman and remains one of the few bourbon brands to have been continuously sold before, during, and after Prohibition.

Old Forester offers a broad range, from its classic 86-proof bottle to the higher-proof Signature 100, and the popular 1920 Prohibition Style, which packs a bold punch. The limited-edition Birthday Bourbon releases are especially prized by collectors. Old Forester earns its spot on our list for combining heritage with innovation and for consistently delivering high-quality bourbon at various proofs and price points.

#11 – Knob Creek

Knob Creek helped ignite the small batch bourbon movement in the 1990s as part of Jim Beam’s premium line. Created by Booker Noe, a sixth-generation distiller, Knob Creek was designed to bring back the fuller, bolder flavor of pre-Prohibition bourbon. It quickly became known for its deep, rich taste and high proof.

The core 9-year Small Batch is a favorite for everyday sipping, while the Single Barrel and 12-Year expressions deliver added depth and complexity. Knob Creek’s balanced mix of sweetness, spice, and oak makes it a staple in bourbon collections. We included it on our list because it offers big flavor, strong age statements, and consistent value—qualities that bourbon lovers truly appreciate.

#10 – Wild Turkey

Wild Turkey is known for its bold flavor, high proof, and no-nonsense attitude. Distilled in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, its roots go back to the 1800s, but the brand gained serious recognition when Jimmy Russell joined in 1954. Now a Master Distiller Emeritus, Russell and his son Eddie have helped shape Wild Turkey into a respected name among both traditionalists and modern bourbon fans.

Signature releases include the classic 101, Rare Breed, and Russell’s Reserve lines. Each bottle delivers a rich, spicy profile with deep oak and vanilla notes, thanks to the brand’s use of a high-rye mash bill and heavy char barrels. Wild Turkey earned its spot on our list for staying true to its punchy, full-flavored style while maintaining strong quality across its range.

#9 – Maker’s Mark

Maker’s Mark is one of the most recognizable names in bourbon, thanks to its iconic red wax seal and signature smoothness. Founded in 1953 by Bill Samuels Sr. in Loretto, Kentucky, Maker’s Mark was one of the first brands to market bourbon as a premium product. The Samuels family famously replaced rye with red winter wheat in the mash bill, creating a softer, sweeter flavor that helped it stand out from traditional spicy bourbons.

The original Maker’s Mark remains the backbone of the brand, but newer expressions like Maker’s 46, Cask Strength, and Private Selection have expanded its appeal to more serious bourbon fans. The distillery’s picturesque setting and hands-on production style also make it one of the most visited in Kentucky. Maker’s Mark made our list for its blend of accessibility, history, and innovation. It’s a bourbon that welcomes newcomers but keeps longtime enthusiasts coming back for more.

#8 – Eagle Rare

Eagle Rare is a standout in the Buffalo Trace family, offering aged elegance at an accessible price—if you can find it. Introduced in 1975 and now produced at Buffalo Trace Distillery, it originally launched as a 101-proof bourbon before settling into its current 90-proof expression. Aged for a minimum of 10 years, Eagle Rare delivers complex layers of vanilla, dark fruit, leather, and oak, making it a go-to for those seeking maturity without the high cost of ultra-premium bottles.

The brand also releases a limited Eagle Rare 17 Year as part of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, which is highly coveted among collectors. With a balance of age, flavor, and value, Eagle Rare has become a bourbon fan favorite and a staple on best-of lists. We selected Eagle Rare for offering a premium sipping experience at a mid-range price point—and proving that “rare” doesn’t always mean out of reach.

#7 – W.L. Weller

W.L. Weller is often called “poor man’s Pappy,” but that nickname sells it short. With a wheated mash bill and ties to the legendary Stitzel-Weller lineage, Weller shares DNA with the most sought-after bourbon in the world—Pappy Van Winkle. Produced by Buffalo Trace, Weller bourbons replace rye with wheat, creating a softer, smoother flavor profile that bourbon fans adore.

The Weller line includes several standout bottles, each with its own following: Weller Special Reserve (the “green label”), Weller Antique 107, and the incredibly hard-to-find Weller 12 Year. More recent additions like Weller Full Proof and CYPB (Craft Your Perfect Bourbon) keep demand sky-high. Weller makes our list for its combination of approachability and excellence. While secondary prices have surged, it’s still one of the best ways to experience the wheated style that made Pappy famous. For collectors and sippers alike, Weller is bourbon royalty in its own right.

#6 – Blanton’s

Blanton’s is the original single barrel bourbon—and a game-changer for the industry. Launched in 1984 by Elmer T. Lee at Buffalo Trace Distillery, it was the first modern bourbon marketed as a premium, single-barrel product. Named after Colonel Albert B. Blanton, a longtime distillery manager, the brand helped elevate bourbon’s image at a time when American whiskey was struggling for relevance.

Each bottle of Blanton’s is drawn from a single barrel, meaning no two bottles are exactly the same. It’s known for its sweet, spicy flavor with notes of caramel, citrus, and vanilla. But the presentation is just as iconic: a rounded bottle with a metal horse stopper, each bearing a letter to spell out “B-L-A-N-T-O-N-S.” Blanton’s earns its spot for setting the bar in premium bourbon and fueling today’s collectible culture. It remains a must-have for new fans and seasoned collectors chasing the full set of stoppers.

#5 – Four Roses

Four Roses is a masterclass in bourbon blending, offering complexity, consistency, and creativity in every bottle. Founded in the late 1800s, the brand was once one of the best-selling bourbons in America before falling into obscurity mid-century. It made a powerful comeback under Japanese ownership (Kirin) and now operates from its distillery in Lawrenceburg and aging warehouses in Cox’s Creek, Kentucky.

What sets Four Roses apart is its unique use of ten distinct recipes, made from two mash bills and five yeast strains. This gives the brand unmatched blending versatility. Their core lineup includes the smooth and spicy Yellow Label (now simply Four Roses Bourbon), the fruit-forward Small Batch, and the bold, complex Single Barrel. At the top, the Limited Edition Small Batch releases are collector favorites. Four Roses made our list for its deep commitment to quality and variety—proving that innovation and tradition can go hand-in-hand in the bourbon world.

#4 – Elijah Craig

Elijah Craig is a legendary name in bourbon, often credited—rightly or not—with inventing the barrel aging process that defines the spirit today. Produced by Heaven Hill in Bardstown, Kentucky, the brand honors a Baptist preacher and early distiller from the late 1700s. While the legend may be debated, the quality of the bourbon is not. Elijah Craig’s lineup includes a standard Small Batch bourbon, but it’s the Barrel Proof editions that have earned it elite status among enthusiasts and critics.

Each Barrel Proof release is uncut and unfiltered, showcasing intense flavor, high proof, and bold character—often winning awards and topping best-of lists. The balance of rich oak, dark caramel, and warm spice makes it a favorite for serious bourbon drinkers. Elijah Craig earns its place on our list for offering both accessibility and top-tier quality, with Barrel Proof expressions that compete with the finest bourbons in the world.

#3 – Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace is a powerhouse in the bourbon world—affordable, accessible, and deeply influential. Produced at the historic Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, Kentucky, the brand dates back to the late 18th century and claims to be the oldest continuously operating distillery in America, even producing “medicinal” whiskey during Prohibition. Its flagship bottle, Buffalo Trace Bourbon, delivers remarkable quality for its price, offering rich caramel, vanilla, and spice notes that appeal to both beginners and seasoned enthusiasts.

The distillery is also home to some of the most sought-after bourbons in the world, including Pappy Van Winkle, Eagle Rare, W.L. Weller, and George T. Stagg. But the Buffalo Trace label itself has become a symbol of excellence in everyday bourbon. Selected for our list because of its role as a cultural backbone of bourbon, it blends heritage and value like few others. For many, this is the bottle that starts the bourbon journey.

#2 – Woodford Reserve

Woodford Reserve stands as a pillar of modern bourbon—elegant, consistent, and deeply respected. Crafted at the historic Woodford Reserve Distillery in Versailles, Kentucky, its lineage traces back to 1812, making it one of the oldest operating distilleries in the U.S. While technically owned by Brown-Forman, the brand maintains a hands-on, small-batch approach that emphasizes quality and character. Its flagship bottle, Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon, is known for its balanced flavor profile—rich with notes of dried fruit, spice, and oak. The Master’s Collection and Double Oaked releases highlight the brand’s innovation and appeal to collectors and connoisseurs alike. Woodford Reserve also has the honor of being the official bourbon of the Kentucky Derby, solidifying its cultural status. Chosen for our list due to its refined craftsmanship and broad appeal, Woodford Reserve delivers an experience that satisfies both casual sippers and seasoned bourbon drinkers with every pour.

#1 – Pappy Van Winkle

Pappy Van Winkle is the crown jewel of bourbon—a name that commands reverence in whiskey circles. Its roots trace back to Julian “Pappy” Van Winkle Sr., who began working in whiskey in the late 1800s and eventually helped shape the Stitzel-Weller distillery legacy. The brand as we know it today is produced by the Buffalo Trace Distillery in partnership with the Van Winkle family, using a wheated bourbon recipe that creates an exceptionally smooth and rich flavor profile. Standout releases like the 15, 20, and 23-year expressions are aged to near-perfection and consistently score high marks among critics and collectors. Pappy’s extreme rarity, coupled with its unmatched quality, has made it a cultural icon—appearing in everything from celebrity bar carts to hip-hop lyrics. Its combination of heritage, craftsmanship, and elusive availability places it firmly at the top of our list. Pappy isn’t just bourbon—it’s a legend.