10 Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails to Try

There’s no better pairing than peanut butter and jelly, even in cocktail form! This cocktail recipe will flood your tastebuds with nostalgia, using peanut butter whiskey and black raspberry liqueur to mimic the classic PB&J flavor. This cocktail is highly alcoholic, with smokey bourbon and sweet vermouth adding a mature complexity to this elegant cocktail.

Emulating Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, this sumptuous cocktail is the best way to drink your dessert. This drink is a simple, one-shaker cocktail, combining chocolate liqueur, milk, and peanut butter whiskey with ice to create the most decadent alcoholic milkshake. This recipe has tips for non-dairy drinkers, too!

An adult twist on a classic after-school snack, this Apple Cider Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktail is a comforting taste of fall. It’s a warm cocktail that combines creamy peanut butter with hot apple cider for unparalleled richness. The cinnamon and brown sugar give the peanut butter and apple flavor a sweet and spicy upgrade. The base recipe makes four cocktails, but you can easily scale up.

This cocktail is another iteration of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, using the same three-ingredient combination of chocolate liqueur, milk, and Skrewball peanut butter whiskey. However, unlike the previous cocktail recipe, this recipe caters even more to amateur mixologists. You don’t need a shaker. Instead, simply pour all the ingredients into individual glasses with ice and stir!

White Russians are typically a vodka and Kahlua drink, but this Skrewball White Russian recipe adds peanut butter whiskey to the mix. Peanut butter and coffee liqueur is the best pairing since peanut butter and jelly! This decadent drink gets a hearty helping of half and half and a smooth peanut butter rim garnish, adding to its extravagance.

Adding a novel and delicious take on a classic, the Peanut Butter Old Fashioned is even simpler than the original recipe. Combining sweet peanut butter whiskey with angostura bitters makes for a perfectly balanced cocktail. The classic cherry and orange peel garnish gives it a peanut butter and jelly-flavored aroma and finish.

The quintessential snack of American childhood, fluffernutters combined marshmallow cream and peanut butter over saltines. You get the same sweet, nutty, and creamy trifecta in this whimsical fluffernutter peanut butter whiskey cocktail, combining marshmallow syrup, Bailey’s, and peanut butter whiskey. The key to its frothiness is the egg white, adding a fluffy texture that reminds me of biting into a marshmallow!

This recipe gives you a double dose of chocolate, peanut butter, cream, and sugar shaken to perfection. It features chocolate in three forms, with crème de cacao, chocolate liqueur, and chocolate bitters. Plus, you get the smokey, sweet peanut butter whiskey plus a dollop of creamy peanut butter with each serving.

The classiest cocktail on the list is perfect in its simplicity, combining peanut butter whiskey and chocolate liqueur in a 1:2 ratio. The wow factor of this recipe is the gorgeous chocolate syrup and grated chocolate garnish. It’s well worth the effort for a special occasion!

Rootbeer floats never tasted so good! Instead of dropping a scoop of ice cream in a glass of root beer, you’ll be mixing in a magical blend of Bailey’s Irish Crème and peanut butter whiskey. The distinctly sweet and botanical taste of root beer with creamy Bailey’s and the nutty sweetness of the peanut butter whiskey is the combination you never knew you needed.