This post may include affiliate links; for details, see our disclosure policy

in , ,

Sleigh Bell Margarita

Sleigh Bell Margarita with a gold sugar rim, pear slice and cinnamon stick next to a fresh pear

The Sleigh Bell Margarita is a spiced pear margarita made with reposado tequila, pear nectar, Cointreau, fresh lime juice and a touch of cinnamon simple syrup. Shake everything together and strain over fresh ice into a sparkling gold sugar rimmed rocks glass. Garnish with a thin pear slice and cinnamon stick. Cheers!

Pear plus cinnamon equals cozy. This spiced pear margarita is cozy in a glass! While I love a margarita in any season, pear and cinnamon syrup give this one the depth you need when the weather is cold out, and it is so easy to make. I can’t wait to make these at my next holiday party!

Save Recipe Form

Why You’ll Love This

Pear and cinnamon just spice things up for the winter months, but this is still a margarita with tequila, orange liqueur and lime.

  • Familiar but festive. Anyone who likes a classic margarita will like this one.
  • The gold rim sparkles. Gold sugar looks like tinsel on the glass and takes ten seconds.
  • Simple to shake. Five ingredients go in the shaker at once.
  • Easy to batch. There is a 10 serving pitcher version below.

Tasting Notes

A reposado tequila is aged in oak, and so it brings a hint of caramel and vanilla which a blanco tequila does not. Pear nectar will soften and round out the margarita, while the lime and Cointreau will remind you it is still a margarita! The cinnamon spice will linger on your palate at the end of each sip. The sugar rim adds a little crunch and sweetness at the beginning of each sip.

Sleigh Bell Margarita with a gold sugar rim, pear slice and cinnamon stick next to a bottle of reposado tequila

Ingredients

Here is everything for one drink, including the rim and the garnish. You’ll need:

  • 2 oz reposado tequila
  • 1 1/2 oz pear nectar
  • 3/4 oz Cointreau
  • 3/4 oz fresh lime juice
  • 1/4 oz cinnamon simple syrup
  • Simple syrup, for the rim
  • Gold sugar, for the rim (or cinnamon sugar)
  • Thin pear slice, for garnish
  • Cinnamon stick, for garnish
  • Ice cubes
See also  Calypso Cooler

Start with a base of Reposado tequila, add some pear nectar (this is where most of the sweetness will come from), a little Cointreau (for that orangey flavor in all margaritas), fresh lime juice and a touch of cinnamon simple syrup (only 1/4 oz but this is what makes it a holiday margarita and not just a pear margarita!). To get the gold sugar to stick, add a little more (regular) simple syrup to the rim!

Sleigh Bell Margarita with reposado tequila, pear nectar, cinnamon syrup and Cointreau behind it

Suggested Liquor Brands and Substitutions

I used Centenario Reposado Tequila, Cointreau and Goya Pear Nectar. Here are a few other options.

  • Centenario Reposado is smooth with a light oak flavor. Espolon or Cazadores reposado are good swaps.
  • Cointreau is my pick for orange liqueur. Triple sec works if that is what you have.
  • Goya Pear Nectar is thick and sweet. Any pear nectar will do.
  • Cinnamon sugar can replace the gold sugar on the rim.
  • Dried pear works for the garnish in place of a fresh pear slice.

Equipment and Glassware

Standard margarita tools are all you need.

Serve it in a rocks glass over ice cubes. You will want two small plates for the rim, one for the simple syrup and one for the gold sugar.

How to Make It

Rim the glass first, then build the drink in the shaker.

Dip the rim of a rocks glass in simple syrup.

Dipping the rim of a rocks glass into a plate of simple syrup

Then dip the rim into gold sugar, or cinnamon sugar, and fully coat the rim. Set the glass aside.

Coating the rim of a rocks glass in gold sugar

Add the tequila to a shaker.

Pouring reposado tequila from a jigger into a glass shaker

Pour in the pear nectar and the Cointreau.

Pouring pear nectar into the shaker

Add the lime juice and the cinnamon syrup.

Pouring cinnamon simple syrup into the shaker

Add ice to the shaker.

Shake vigorously until chilled.

Shaking the Sleigh Bell Margarita with ice

Strain over fresh ice in the rimmed rocks glass.

Straining the margarita over fresh ice in a gold rimmed rocks glass

Garnish with a thin pear slice and a cinnamon stick.

Adding a cinnamon stick to a Sleigh Bell Margarita with a pear slice

Batch Version

You can make a pitcher of this ahead of time, so all you have to do is pour the cocktail over ice. This makes 10 servings.

  • 20 oz reposado tequila
  • 15 oz pear nectar
  • 7 1/2 oz Cointreau
  • 7 1/2 oz fresh lime juice
  • 2 1/2 oz cinnamon simple syrup
  • Gold sugar or cinnamon sugar, for rims
  • Thin pear slices, for garnish
  • Cinnamon sticks, for garnish
See also  Penitent Punch

Combine the tequila, pear nectar, Cointreau, lime juice and cinnamon simple syrup in a pitcher and stir. Chill until ready to serve. To serve, rim the glasses with simple syrup and gold sugar, fill with ice and pour in the pear margarita. Garnish each one with a cinnamon stick and a slice of pear.

Pro Tips

  • Adjust the sweetness. If the original recipe is too sweet for you, use less pear nectar and less simple syrup.
  • Rim only the outside. Roll the outer edge of the glass through the syrup so sugar does not fall into the drink.
  • Use fresh ice in the glass. The ice in the shaker breaks down as you shake, so strain over new cubes.
  • Slice the pear right before serving. Cut pear browns quickly, so garnish at the last minute.

When to Serve

Serve with chips and queso or a cheese board (pears and blue cheese are good choices). Basically, anything salty. If your get-togethers revolve around margaritas, this is an easy way to make your cocktail menu feel more December-y. Wonderfully festive with its gold-rimmed glass, this drink would be perfect for holiday parties, tamale nights and Christmas Eve dinners, and, because of its gold rim, New Year’s Eve as well.

Close up of a Sleigh Bell Margarita with a gold sugar rim, a pear slice and a cinnamon stick

FAQs

What does a Sleigh Bell Margarita taste like?

Like a margarita, but with pear and cinnamon. Slightly sweeter and less harsh than your traditional margarita.

Can I use blanco tequila?

You could also use a blanco tequila here if preferred. Reposado has a warmer, oaky flavor that complements the pear and cinnamon but a blanco would result in a brighter cocktail.

Where do I find gold sugar?

Look for gold sanding sugar in the baking aisle with the sprinkles. Cinnamon sugar is an easy swap.

Can I make it ahead?

Prepare a batch and store in the refrigerator until ready to serve. When you’re ready to serve, pour it over ice.

See also  Rhubarb Margarita

Similar Cocktails

Save Recipe Form

Sleigh Bell Margarita with a gold sugar rim, pear slice and cinnamon stick next to a fresh pear

Sleigh Bell Margarita

Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
No ratings yet
Course: Drinks
Cuisine: American
Keyword: Christmas cocktails, cinnamon syrup, cointreau, Margarita, Pear nectar, reposado tequila
Servings: 1 drink
Author: Jenna Haley
A spiced pear margarita with reposado tequila, pear nectar, Cointreau, lime and cinnamon syrup, served over ice with a gold sugar rim.

Ingredients

Gold Sugar Rim

  • Simple syrup for the rim
  • Gold sugar for the rim, or cinnamon sugar

Margarita

Instructions

Gold Sugar Rim

  • Dip the rim of a rocks glass in simple syrup.
  • Dip the rim into gold sugar or cinnamon sugar and fully coat it.
  • Set the glass aside.

Margarita

  • Add tequila, pear nectar, Cointreau, lime juice and cinnamon syrup to a shaker.
  • Add ice to the shaker.
  • Shake vigorously until chilled.
  • Strain over fresh ice in the rimmed rocks glass.
  • Garnish with a thin pear slice and cinnamon stick.

Notes

If it is too sweet for you, use less pear nectar and less simple syrup.
Batch version (10 servings): stir together 20 oz reposado tequila, 15 oz pear nectar, 7 1/2 oz Cointreau, 7 1/2 oz fresh lime juice and 2 1/2 oz cinnamon simple syrup in a pitcher. Chill, then pour over ice in rimmed glasses.
Tried this recipe?Leave a comment and let us know how it was!
Please drink responsibly, be fully accountable with your alcohol consumption, and show others respect.

Leave a Reply

Avatar

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Jenna Haley

Written by Jenna Haley

Holly Jolly Spritz with rosemary and pomegranate seeds next to a wrapped Christmas gift

Holly Jolly Spritz

White Christmas Martini with a toasted coconut rim next to a box of Raffaello candy and a candle

White Christmas Martini