Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned

There’s something special about a winter cocktail that warms you from the inside out, and this Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned has become one of my favorite ways to unwind during the colder months. It brings together everything I love about the season rich bourbon, warm spices, and that soothing chai flavor that feels like a soft blanket. The first time I made this drink was during a snowstorm when all I wanted was something comforting but still a little fancy. After one sip, I knew it was going into my yearly holiday rotation.

What makes this winter drink recipe so good is its balance. The bourbon stays bold and smooth, but the chai syrup adds a mellow sweetness with cozy notes of cinnamon and cardamom. The vanilla rounds it out without overpowering anything, giving the whole drink a soft, warm finish. I especially love making this cocktail for friends because it feels familiar and classic, but still new enough to spark conversation. It’s the kind of holiday cocktail you can curl up with after dinner or enjoy at a festive gathering.

If you’re a fan of Old Fashioneds but want one that fits the winter mood perfectly, this is the drink to try. The homemade chai simple syrup is easy to make and adds a depth of flavor you just can’t get from store-bought mixers. Once you taste it, you may find yourself adding it to your coffee, hot chocolate, and pretty much anything that needs a little holiday vibe.

---

Why You’ll Love This

A Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned hits all the best parts of a classic Old Fashioned while giving you something warmer and more seasonal. It blends familiar bourbon character with the comfort of chai tea, turning a simple cocktail into one that feels perfect for December nights or any chilly evening. The spice level is gentle but noticeable, and the vanilla gives the drink a smooth finish that’s great for sipping slowly.

Here are some of the standout perks:

• A cozy holiday cocktail that feels perfect for winter
• Easy homemade chai syrup that tastes fresh and aromatic
• A fun twist on a classic bourbon drink
• Great for slow sipping by the fireplace or serving at parties
• Perfect balance of sweet, spiced, and citrus notes
• Simple ingredients that still feel impressive

When you serve this cocktail, people always notice that soft chai aroma first and it makes them excited to take that first sip.

Ingredients

This drink uses a combination of warm spices, citrus, bourbon, and a simple vanilla chai syrup that ties everything together. Each ingredient has a purpose, and once blended, they create a winter drink that feels layered and comforting.

To Make the Chai Simple Syrup:

• 4 chai tea bags
• 1 cup water
• 1 tablespoon sugar
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

To Make the Old Fashioned:

• 2 oz bourbon
• 1 oz lemon juice
• 1 dash Angostura bitters
• 1 oz chai simple syrup
• Cinnamon stick, star anise and orange slice for garnish

The chai bags give the syrup a full, flavorful base, while the sugar adds a little sweetness that helps the syrup blend smoothly into the cocktail. The vanilla adds a warm finish that ties in beautifully with bourbon. Fresh lemon juice brings brightness, while the bitters keep everything balanced.

Suggested Liquor Brands and Substitutions

Because this cocktail is bourbon-forward, choosing a good bottle makes a difference. You don’t need something too expensive, but you also want a smooth bourbon with enough structure to hold its own against the chai flavors. These picks work especially well:

• Buffalo Trace: A classic, smooth bourbon that blends beautifully with warm spices.
• Four Roses Small Batch: Slightly fruity notes that pair well with the vanilla.
• Bulleit Bourbon: A spicier bourbon that plays nicely with chai.
• Maker’s Mark: A sweeter bourbon that softens the cocktail.
• Woodford Reserve: Rich and full-bodied for a stronger bourbon presence.
• Substitution: If you don’t have bourbon, spiced rum or rye whiskey can give a different but still tasty twist.

If you want to experiment, choosing a more robust bourbon will bring out deeper spice tones, while a softer one will keep the drink mellow.

Equipment and Glassware

You don’t need much to make a great Old Fashioned at home, which makes this drink especially approachable. Everything can be prepared with basic home equipment while still giving you a polished, bar-quality drink.

You’ll need:

• A small saucepan
• A mixing glass
• A long bar spoon
• A fine mesh strainer
• A rocks glass
• A large ice cube (recommended for slower dilution)

A sturdy rocks glass works best for presentation, since it showcases the spices and garnish while keeping the drink easy to sip.

How to Make It

This cocktail has two parts: the vanilla chai simple syrup and the Old Fashioned itself. Both are easy, and once you make the syrup, you can use it in multiple drinks throughout the week. The process fills your kitchen with that warm chai aroma, which makes it perfect for winter evenings.

To Make the Chai Simple Syrup:

1. Bring 1 cup of water to a boil in a small pot.
2. Remove from heat, add the chai tea bags, cover, and let steep for 10–15 minutes.
3. Discard the tea bags, then stir in the sugar while the tea is still warm.
4. Bring the mixture back to a gentle simmer for about 3 minutes, then remove from heat.
5. Stir in vanilla extract and let it cool completely. Store in the refrigerator for up to two weeks.

To Make the Old Fashioned:

1. In a mixing glass, add bourbon, lemon juice, bitters, and chai syrup.
2. Fill with ice and stir until the drink is fully chilled.
3. Strain into a rocks glass with a large ice cube.
4. Garnish with a cinnamon stick, star anise and orange slice.

You can always adjust the sweetness or spice by adding a little more syrup or bitters until it fits exactly what you like.

Pro Tips

A few thoughtful tricks make this Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned even better. These tips help you control dilution, balance, and flavor strength so each sip tastes intentional and smooth.

• Use a large ice cube to slow the melting process and keep the drink balanced longer.
• Let the syrup fully cool before using it so it doesn’t water down the drink.
• Taste the chai steeping liquid before adding sugar; steep longer for a stronger spice flavor.
• Try fresh lemon juice only for the cleanest citrus note.
• Use high-quality bitters since they affect the final flavor more than you might think.
• Keep the mixing glass chilled if you like your Old Fashioneds extra cold.
• Strain carefully so the drink stays clear and smooth.
• Experiment with different bourbons to find your favorite flavor pairing.

Once you get comfortable, the chai syrup becomes a fun tool to tweak sweetness and spice levels across different winter cocktails.

Variations

One of the best things about this cocktail is how easy it is to customize. Small changes can give you a totally different drink while still keeping that comforting chai and bourbon base.

Here are a few ideas:

• Swap bourbon for spiced rum for a sweeter, softer winter drink.
• Add a splash of orange bitters for a brighter citrus note.
• Use honey instead of sugar in the syrup for a floral twist.
• Add a bit of fresh grated ginger to the syrup for more bite.
• Make a non-alcoholic version with non-alcoholic bourbon and extra chai syrup.

Each variation brings its own personality, making this drink easy to tailor for holidays or personal tastes.

When to Serve and Pairings

This Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned is an excellent choice for holiday gatherings, winter celebrations, or quiet nights at home. It’s cozy, polished, and has that elegant spice profile that people associate with seasonal cocktails. It also makes a great after-dinner drink because of the warm, lingering spices and the mellow sweetness.

Perfect pairings include:

• Gingerbread cookies
• Dark chocolate desserts
• Spiced nuts
• Cheese boards with sharp cheddar or aged gouda
• Warm pastries or cinnamon rolls
• Holiday appetizers like bacon-wrapped dates

You can also serve this cocktail alongside other festive drinks like a Cranberry Whiskey Sour or a Hot Buttered Rum for a full winter drink lineup.

Storage and Serving Notes

The chai simple syrup lasts up to two weeks in the refrigerator, making it perfect for prepping ahead of the holiday season. Always store it in an airtight container and shake it lightly before using if any separation occurs. The syrup may thicken slightly as it chills, so you can warm it gently or stir before adding to your cocktails.

For batching, you can pre-mix the cocktail ingredients (except the ice) in a sealed jar or pitcher. When ready to serve, just pour over fresh ice and garnish.

FAQs

Here are some helpful answers to common questions about making this holiday cocktail at home.

Can I use a different tea for the syrup?
Yes, black tea or an herbal chai blend works well, but the flavor will change slightly.

Can I make the syrup sweeter?
Add an extra tablespoon of sugar or simmer a little longer for a thicker result.

Do I have to use lemon juice?
A small amount of citrus brightens the drink, but you can reduce it if you prefer a more traditional Old Fashioned flavor.

Can this be made into a mocktail?
Yes. Replace bourbon with a non-alcoholic whiskey alternative and keep the rest the same.

How strong is the chai flavor?
You control the intensity by how long the tea steeps. For stronger spice, steep the full 15 minutes.

More Cocktails to Try

If you enjoy winter cocktail recipes or warm, spiced drinks, here are a few more ideas you might love:

• Honeycrisp Apple Sangria
• Spiked Pumpkin Horchata
• Holiday Cheer Sangria
• White Christmas Margarita
• Tinseltini