Snowy evenings and early sunsets are when I reach for old fashioned variations that feel warmer and more layered. The first time I made this Winter Spice Old Fashioned, it was one of those nights when the house was quiet, the lights were low, and a slow sip felt like the right pace. That first taste confirmed it, this is the kind of winter cocktail that makes you want to settle in.
This Winter Spice Old Fashioned is a holiday recipe that works just as well for a quiet night as it does for entertaining. If you enjoy winter cocktails with bold character and balance, this one deserves a spot in your rotation. It is thoughtful, warming, and easy to return to once you have made it once.
Why You’ll Love This Winter Spice Old Fashioned
This Winter Spice Old Fashioned cocktail is strong, spiced, lightly bitter, and smooth. It keeps the bourbon at the center while adding enough sweetness and herbal character to make the drink more layered.
A few reasons this drink works well:
- Bourbon stays front and center. The drink still feels spirit-forward.
- Cynar adds bitterness. It keeps the syrup from making the drink too sweet.
- Cardamom and clove add warm spice. Both fit naturally with bourbon.
- Angostura ties everything together. It adds more spice and depth.
- It is stirred, not shaken. The texture stays smooth and clear.
- The garnish is simple. One star anise gives the drink a finished winter look.
This is a good choice when you want a colder-weather whiskey cocktail with more bitterness and spice than a standard Old Fashioned.
Ingredients
The Winter Spice Old Fashioned combines bourbon with Cynar, spiced syrup, and aromatic bitters.
You will need:
- 2 ounces bourbon whiskey
- ½ ounce Cynar
- ½ ounce cardamom and clove simple syrup
- 3 dashes Angostura bitters
- Star anise for garnish
Bourbon gives the Winter Spice Old Fashioned cocktail its base and brings vanilla, caramel, oak, and spice.
Cynar adds a darker herbal bitterness.
The cardamom and clove syrup adds sweetness and warm spice, while Angostura gives the drink another layer of aromatic depth.
Suggested Liquor Brands and Substitutions
A balanced bourbon works best because the Cynar and syrup already bring plenty of flavor.
Here are a few options:
- Buffalo Trace: Smooth with caramel and vanilla notes.
- Woodford Reserve: Richer with more oak and spice.
- Maker’s Mark: Softer and slightly sweeter.
- Bulleit Bourbon: Drier with a stronger spice note.
- Rye whiskey: Use it instead of bourbon for a sharper finish.
- Amaro Montenegro: Use it instead of Cynar for a softer, less bitter herbal note.
If your cardamom and clove syrup is especially sweet, a drier bourbon or rye can help keep the drink balanced.
Equipment and Glassware
You only need a few basic tools for this Winter Spice Old Fashioned cocktail.
You will need:
A coupe works well because the cocktail is served up without ice.
Chilling the glass first can help the drink stay cold a little longer.
How to Make a Winter Spice Old Fashioned
Stir the ingredients with plenty of ice, then strain into a coupe.
- Fill a mixing glass with plenty of ice.
- Pour in the bourbon, Cynar, and cardamom and clove simple syrup.
- Add three dashes of Angostura bitters to the mixture.
- Stir the cocktail until it is well-chilled and the ingredients are thoroughly combined.
- Strain the cocktail into a coupe glass.
- Garnish with a star anise for a warm, aromatic finish.
The finished cocktail should taste bourbon-forward, spiced, lightly sweet, and bitter with an herbal finish.
Pro Tips
A few small details can help this drink stay balanced.
- Use plenty of ice. It helps chill the drink without over-diluting it.
- Stir until the glass feels cold. This gives the cocktail the right amount of water.
- Measure the syrup carefully. Too much can make the drink heavy.
- Use a balanced bourbon. Very sweet whiskey can make the cocktail feel soft.
- Keep the star anise to one piece. Its aroma is strong.
- Chill the coupe if possible. It helps the drink stay colder.
- Use fresh bitters. They add more aromatic depth.
- Serve right away. This cocktail is best while properly chilled.
If the drink tastes too sweet, reduce the syrup slightly next time.
Variations
The Winter Spice Old Fashioned is easy to adjust while keeping the same bourbon-and-spice structure.
- Rye Version: Replace bourbon with rye whiskey.
- Orange Version: Express an orange peel over the top before serving.
- Less Bitter Version: Replace Cynar with a softer amaro.
- Maple Version: Replace part of the spiced syrup with maple syrup.
- Rocks Version: Serve over one large ice cube instead of in a coupe.
You can also add one extra dash of bitters if you want a drier finish.
When to Serve and Pairings
The Winter Spice Old Fashioned works well for holiday dinners, winter cocktail hour, Christmas parties, or quiet evenings at home.
Its bourbon, bitter herbs, clove, cardamom, and spice flavors pair well with richer savory foods and desserts.
Try it with:
- Roast beef
- Baked brie
- Aged cheddar
- Roasted nuts
- Charcuterie
- Pecan pie
- Dark chocolate
- Shortbread
It also fits well beside drinks such as the Maple Butter Old Fashioned, Bourbon Persimmon Cocktail, Apple Cider Manhattan, or Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned.
If your menu already includes several sweet or creamy cocktails, this gives you a stronger spirit-forward option.
Storage and Serving Notes
The Winter Spice Old Fashioned is best stirred and served fresh.
You can pre-measure the bourbon, Cynar, syrup, and bitters ahead of time.
Keep the mixture chilled if you are preparing several servings.
Stir each portion with fresh ice before pouring.
You can also batch the liquid ingredients in advance, then measure individual servings into a mixing glass.
Add the star anise only after straining.
FAQs
What does a Winter Spice Old Fashioned taste like?
It tastes strong, spiced, lightly sweet, herbal, and bitter with bourbon at the center.
What does Cynar add to the drink?
Cynar adds an earthy herbal bitterness that balances the syrup and bourbon.
Can I use rye instead of bourbon?
Yes. Rye makes the drink drier and spicier.
Can I serve it over ice?
Yes. One large cube works well if you prefer a slower-sipping version.
Can I make it less sweet?
Yes. Reduce the cardamom and clove syrup slightly.
Can I make this cocktail ahead of time?
Yes. Pre-mix the liquid ingredients, then stir each serving with ice before pouring.
More Cocktails to Try
If you like stirred whiskey cocktails with spice, bitterness, and seasonal flavors, these drinks fit well into the same lineup.
- Maple Butter Old Fashioned: Bourbon, maple butter, bitters, orange, and cinnamon make a richer fall whiskey drink.
- Bourbon Persimmon Cocktail: Bourbon, persimmon syrup, and orange bitters make a fruit-forward seasonal option.
- Apple Cider Manhattan: Whiskey, apple cider, vermouth, and bitters make another stirred fall cocktail.
- Vanilla Chai Old Fashioned: Whiskey and chai spice make a warmer aromatic drink.
- Bitter Apple Negroni: Apple whiskey, aperitif wine, Suze, and apple cinnamon syrup make a more bitter seasonal cocktail.
These give you a mix of bourbon, rye, fruit, spice, and herbal bitterness for fall and winter cocktail menus.

Ingredients
- 2 ounces bourbon whiskey
- ½ ounce Cynar
- ½ ounce cardamom and clove simple syrup
- 3 dashes Angostura bitters
- Star anise for garnish
Instructions
- Fill a mixing glass with plenty of ice.
- Pour in the bourbon, Cynar, and cardamom and clove simple syrup.
- Add three dashes of Angostura bitters to the mixture.
- Stir the cocktail until it is well-chilled and the ingredients are thoroughly combined.
- Strain the cocktail into a coupe glass.
- Garnish with a star anise for a warm, aromatic finish.
Notes
Pro Tips
- For a homemade cardamom and clove simple syrup, simmer equal parts water and sugar with a few cardamom pods and whole cloves. Strain and cool before using.
- If you prefer a slightly less bitter drink, reduce the Cynar to a quarter-ounce for a more balanced flavor.
- Chilling the coupe glass beforehand keeps the cocktail cold longer and enhances the sipping experience.



