Mrs. Claus’s Eggnog

Holiday drinks have a way of setting the mood, and Mrs. Claus’s Eggnog might be one of the most charming Christmas cocktails you can make. The first time I mixed this for friends, it instantly became the kind of drink people talked about long after the night ended. It is creamy, lightly spiced, and warm in flavor, which makes it feel like it belongs beside twinkling lights and a crackling fire.

This recipe works well for Christmas Eve gatherings, holiday parties, or even a low key winter night when you want something comforting. It is simple to make but feels special, especially when served in a festive mug or chilled rocks glass. If you enjoy dessert cocktails or cozy winter drinks, Mrs. Claus’s Eggnog gives you all the nostalgia of the holidays in one sip.

---

Why You’ll Love This

Mrs. Claus’s Eggnog brings together the best flavors of the holiday season in a creamy, spiced cocktail that is easy to prepare. It works well for entertaining because the recipe is forgiving and pairs beautifully with many sweet treats. The cinnamon sugar rim adds a decorative touch that makes the drink feel thoughtfully made.

Reasons it is a holiday favorite:

• Simple ingredients that blend smoothly every time.
• Warm cinnamon notes that create a classic Christmas flavor.
• RumChata gives the drink a velvety finish without overpowering it.
• Eye catching garnish that adds aroma and festive charm.
• Works both on ice and served straight up, depending on your mood.

Together, these features make the drink a reliable go to for winter gatherings.

Ingredients

Every ingredient in this cocktail helps build a layered and cozy flavor profile. Eggnog brings rich creaminess, cinnamon whiskey adds warmth, and RumChata gives a sweet cinnamon vanilla finish. The optional cinnamon sugar rim is worth adding because it enhances both the flavor and presentation.

• 3 oz eggnog
• 1.5 oz Cinnamon Whiskey
• 1 oz RumChata
• Splash half and half
• Cinnamon sugar for rimming
• Cinnamon stick for garnish

Eggnog acts as the base and sets the tone for a creamy dessert like drink. Cinnamon whiskey gives the cocktail a spicy warmth that balances the sweetness. RumChata blends seamlessly with the other ingredients, providing a creamy cinnamon note. The splash of half and half lightens the eggnog just enough to make the drink feel smooth and balanced.

Suggested Liquor Brands and Substitutions

Choosing the right cinnamon whiskey or cream liqueur can enhance the flavor of this holiday drink. You do not need anything fancy, but certain brands blend especially well with eggnog. You can also make substitutions if you want the drink slightly sweeter, creamier, or lighter.

Recommended options include:

• Cinnamon Whiskey: Fireball is a popular choice because it blends gently without overwhelming the eggnog.
• Cream Liqueur Substitute: Bailey’s Vanilla Cinnamon can replace RumChata for a similar flavor profile.
• Eggnog Options: Store bought works well, but homemade eggnog adds richer texture.
• Half and Half Swap: Light cream creates a thicker, more indulgent finish.
• Cinnamon Sugar Rim: Brown sugar mixed with cinnamon gives a deeper caramel flavor.

These small choices let you customize the drink to your preferred sweetness and richness.

Equipment and Glassware

You will not need many tools to make Mrs. Claus’s Eggnog, which is part of what makes it perfect for quick holiday entertaining. A simple shaker and a festive glass or mug will do the trick. The rimmed glass adds visual appeal and is worth preparing if you want the drink to feel extra special.

Useful tools include:

• Cocktail Shaker
• Strainer
• Rocks Glass
• Jigger

Choosing a glass that shows off the pale creamy color can help make the presentation feel warm and inviting.

How to Make It

This cocktail comes together easily, and the gentle shaking helps blend the dairy ingredients into a smooth, frothy texture. The cinnamon sugar rim is optional but recommended for an added touch of sweetness and sparkle.

1. Mix equal parts cinnamon and sugar on a small plate. Moisten the rim of your glass with water or eggnog, then dip the rim into the mixture.
2. Add eggnog, cinnamon whiskey, RumChata, and a splash of half and half to a shaker filled with ice.
3. Shake gently until the ingredients are well chilled and blended.
4. Strain the mixture into your prepared glass, either over ice or straight up.
5. Grate fresh cinnamon over the top and garnish with a cinnamon stick.

Some people like adding a small amount of vanilla extract for extra warmth, so you can experiment with that depending on your taste.

Pro Tips

A few thoughtful adjustments can make Mrs. Claus’s Eggnog even better. Since this is a creamy drink, balancing the textures and spices helps create a smooth, flavorful cocktail. These tips will help you perfect the recipe for guests or personal enjoyment.

• Chill the eggnog before mixing for a smoother texture.
• Use fresh grated cinnamon instead of pre ground for better aroma.
• Shake gently instead of vigorously to prevent over frothing.
• Add one more splash of half and half if the drink tastes too thick.
• Use crushed ice if you prefer an icier, lighter texture.
• Serve in a chilled glass to keep the drink cold without excessive dilution.
• Try a caramel drizzle inside the glass for extra sweetness.

These little tricks help customize the cocktail so it suits your holiday mood.

Variations

It is easy to adjust this recipe to fit your flavor preferences or dietary needs. You can make the drink richer, lighter, or more spiced with just a few simple changes. All versions still keep the festive spirit of the original.

• Use vanilla whiskey instead of cinnamon for a smoother flavor.
• Add nutmeg for a classic eggnog spice note.
• Replace RumChata with almond milk liqueur for a lighter finish.
• Make a frozen version by blending with ice instead of shaking.
• Create a kid friendly version by skipping alcohol and adding cinnamon syrup to eggnog.

These variations let you enjoy the drink in new ways all season long.

When to Serve and Pairings

Mrs. Claus’s Eggnog is a natural choice for Christmas cocktails, holiday dessert spreads, winter celebrations, and cozy evenings indoors. It works beautifully after a festive dinner or as a signature sip for gift wrapping or tree decorating parties. The flavor pairs easily with many winter treats.

Consider serving it with:

• Cookies such as snickerdoodles or gingerbread
• Holiday desserts like fruitcake or yule log
• Savory snacks such as spiced nuts
• Other Christmas cocktails like a Sugar Cookie Martini or RumChata Martini

These pairings highlight the sweetness and spice of the eggnog.

Storage and Serving Notes

This cocktail is best enjoyed fresh, but you can prepare some parts ahead to save time. If you want to make a batch, mix the eggnog, RumChata, cinnamon whiskey, and half and half in advance and keep the mixture chilled. Shake individual servings with ice to maintain the right texture.

Do not rim glasses ahead of time because the sugar mixture can dissolve. Prepare garnishes just before serving to keep everything fresh and aromatic.

FAQs

If you are new to making creamy cocktails, these questions may help answer common concerns and ensure the drink turns out perfectly.

Can I make this cocktail hot instead of cold?
Yes, gently warm the eggnog mixture on the stove, but do not boil. Serve in a mug without ice.

Is homemade eggnog better?
Homemade eggnog gives a richer flavor, but store bought works very well and is easier for entertaining.

Can I use less alcohol?
Absolutely. Reduce the cinnamon whiskey to 1 oz or use a lighter cream liqueur.

What if I do not have RumChata?
Try a vanilla cream liqueur or a cinnamon flavored cream liqueur.

Does the drink thicken as it sits?
Yes, the dairy and spices can settle. Stir gently if needed.

More Cocktails to Try

If you enjoy festive, creamy, or dessert inspired cocktails, here are a few more recipes to explore. Each one brings a warm and delicious twist to your holiday celebrations.

• Espresso Sugar Cookie Martini: A sweet and creamy treat inspired by holiday cookies.
• Cinnamon Roll Espresso Martini: A smooth and spiced cocktail with warm cinnamon notes.
• Gingerbread White Russian: A dessert like drink with cozy winter spices.
• Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot: A fun, sweet shot with cinnamon flavor.
• Pomegranate Prosecco Winter Punch: A lighter, fruit forward option for festive gatherings.