Mistletoe Manhattan

Holiday gatherings always seem to call for a cocktail that feels classic but still carries a little seasonal charm, and the Mistletoe Manhattan fits that moment perfectly. This winter twist on a timeless drink blends whiskey with cherry, cranberry, and bitters for a smooth sip that feels warm and comforting. I first made it during a family Christmas dinner when I wanted something traditional but dressed up for the season, and everyone ended up asking for seconds.

What makes this holiday recipe special is how the fruit notes gently soften the bold whiskey without covering it up. The maraschino cherry juice adds richness, while the cranberry brings a tart edge that keeps the drink bright. I love that this cocktail manages to taste both familiar and fresh, which makes it great for anyone who enjoys classic spirits but wants a festive twist. The rosemary garnish adds a subtle aroma that instantly reminds me of winter nights and holiday cooking.

This cocktail also looks beautiful in the glass. With its deep red tones and seasonal garnishes, the Mistletoe Manhattan shines at Christmas parties, holiday dinners, and quiet evenings when you want a drink that feels thoughtful. Whether you are mixing one for yourself or preparing a batch for guests, it offers a polished, cozy experience that suits any winter cocktail lineup.

---

Why You’ll Love This

The Mistletoe Manhattan brings together classic whiskey flavors with subtle holiday accents that make it perfect for Christmas cocktails and winter gatherings.

It has a smooth, layered taste that feels both bold and festive, making it a great choice for anyone who likes refined drinks. I enjoy it because it feels more special than a standard Manhattan without becoming overly sweet or complicated.

Here are some reasons this drink becomes a seasonal favorite:

• It uses simple ingredients while still feeling elevated and celebratory.
• The cherry and cranberry add color and flavor that fit winter holidays.
• Whiskey lovers appreciate how the fruit elements complement the spirit.
• It is quick to prepare, which helps when serving several guests.
• The rosemary garnish adds a gentle aroma that ties the whole drink together.
• It works well before dinner or as a slow sipping cocktail afterward.

All these elements make the Mistletoe Manhattan a thoughtful yet approachable drink for the season.

Ingredients

This recipe is built on classic Manhattan components but enhanced with flavors that reflect winter and holiday celebrations. Each ingredient contributes to a smooth, rich balance. The fruit juices lighten the Manhattan slightly while the bitters ground it in tradition.

• 2 oz whiskey
• ½ oz maraschino cherry juice
• ½ oz cranberry juice
• ½ oz sweet vermouth
• 2 dashes Angostura bitters
• cherry for garnish
• cranberries for garnish
• rosemary sprig for garnish

Every component plays an important role in shaping the drink. The whiskey brings warmth and depth. Maraschino juice adds sweetness and richness, while the cranberry provides a brighter tang.

Sweet vermouth rounds everything out and blends the flavors smoothly. Angostura bitters add a classic touch that ties it back to the Manhattan we know and love.

Suggested Liquor Brands and Substitutions

Selecting the right whiskey can make this holiday recipe shine even more. You do not need a premium bottle, but choosing something smooth and balanced helps the fruit flavors integrate comfortably. Vermouth and bitters also play a big role in the overall character, and there are easy substitutions if you want to adjust the drink.

Here are some recommended options:

• Bulleit Bourbon offers a warm, slightly spicy profile that blends well with cherry and cranberry.
• Woodford Reserve gives a smooth, rich taste that works beautifully in winter cocktails.
• Maker’s Mark adds a softer sweetness that complements the fruit notes.
• Rittenhouse Rye brings bold spice if you prefer a stronger Manhattan base.
• Luxardo cherry syrup can be used instead of maraschino juice for a deeper flavor.
• Dry vermouth works in place of sweet vermouth for a more restrained sweetness.

These choices make it easy to personalize the drink while keeping the flavors cozy and balanced.

Equipment and Glassware

The Mistletoe Manhattan keeps things simple when it comes to equipment. Most home bartenders already have what they need. A chilled coupe or martini glass helps highlight the drink’s deep color and gives it a polished presentation for holiday gatherings.

Helpful tools include:

• Cocktail Shaker
• Bar Spoon
• Rocks Glass
• Jigger

While a shaker works well for this version because of the juice components, you can also stir it if you prefer a more traditional Manhattan texture.

How to Make It

Making a Mistletoe Manhattan is quick, straightforward, and perfect for winter hosting. The ingredients blend easily, and the color develops nicely as everything comes together. Preparing your garnishes before mixing helps the final drink look complete.

1. Fill a cocktail shaker with ice.
2. Add whiskey, maraschino cherry juice, cranberry juice, sweet vermouth, and Angostura bitters.
3. Shake or gently stir the mixture a few times until chilled.
4. Strain into a chilled glass.
5. Garnish with a maraschino cherry, a few cranberries, and a rosemary sprig.

If you prefer the drink stronger and more spirit forward, reduce the cranberry juice slightly. For a sweeter profile, increase the maraschino cherry juice.

Pro Tips

Small choices can help elevate the flavor and texture of this holiday cocktail. These tips will help you get the best possible result, especially if you are making the drink for guests. I find that even a tiny adjustment can change the overall feel of the drink in a noticeable way.

• Use a quality sweet vermouth to keep the flavors smooth and well balanced.
• Chill your glass to help maintain the drink’s cold temperature.
• Taste before serving in case you want to adjust sweetness or tartness.
• Experiment with bourbon or rye to see which whiskey style you prefer.
• Use large ice cubes for shaking so the drink does not over dilute.
• Try Luxardo cherries for a richer garnish that pairs nicely with the whiskey.
• Adjust the bitters depending on how bold you want the finish to be.

Playing with these small changes can help you create a version of the Mistletoe Manhattan that fits your taste perfectly.

Variations

This holiday cocktail adapts easily to different styles and preferences. You can make it sweeter, stronger, or lighter depending on the occasion. A few quick changes can give you a brand new version while keeping the seasonal spirit alive.

Try these variations:

• Use rye whiskey for a spicier, bolder Manhattan.
• Add a splash of orange juice for a softer holiday flavor.
• Replace cranberry juice with pomegranate juice for a deeper color.
• Make a zero proof version with non alcohol whiskey alternatives.
• Add a small dash of cinnamon syrup for a warm, wintery touch.

These adjustments let you tailor the drink for different crowds or holiday moods.

When to Serve and Pairings

The Mistletoe Manhattan fits beautifully into many seasonal moments. It works well before a holiday dinner because it feels smooth and comforting without filling you up. I also enjoy serving it during gift exchanges or quiet nights by the fireplace because the whiskey base gives it a relaxing feel that pairs nicely with winter evenings.

Try serving it with:

• Charcuterie boards with sharp or soft cheeses
• Cranberry glazed meats or appetizers
• Chocolate truffles or rich desserts
• Spiced nuts or holiday snack mixes
• Other winter cocktails like a Christmas Collins or Winter Old Fashioned

These pairings help highlight the fruity and herbal flavors in the drink.

Storage and Serving Notes

This cocktail is best served fresh, but you can prepare a batch ahead of time if you are hosting. Mix the whiskey, vermouth, cherry juice, cranberry juice, and bitters in a sealed container and store it in the refrigerator. When ready to serve, shake or stir each portion with ice, then strain into a chilled glass.

Avoid adding garnishes until right before serving so they stay bright and fragrant. If batching, taste the mixture beforehand and adjust sweetness or tartness to your liking.

FAQs

These common questions can help you perfect your Mistletoe Manhattan or tailor it to fit different preferences.

Can I use bourbon instead of whiskey?
Yes, bourbon works wonderfully and adds a slightly sweeter, richer flavor.

Is it better shaken or stirred?
Shaking blends the juices more thoroughly, while stirring gives a smoother, more traditional Manhattan texture.

What can I use instead of sweet vermouth?
Dry vermouth or red Italian aperitifs can work, though the flavor will shift slightly.

Can I make this drink sweeter?
Increase the maraschino cherry juice or add a small splash of simple syrup.

Does the rosemary change the flavor?
It adds a subtle aroma but does not overpower the drink. It is mostly decorative and seasonal.

More Cocktails to Try

If you enjoy Christmas cocktails that blend classic flavors with seasonal twists, here are a few more recipes that fit the holiday mood. Each one brings its own personality and works well for winter gatherings.

• Christmas Collins: A bubbly blend of gin, pomegranate, lime, and rosemary.
• White Winter Margarita: A lightly herbal margarita made with white cranberry juice and citrus.
• Winter Honey Old Fashioned: A deeper whiskey cocktail and bitters.
• Santa’s Pomegranate Punch: A sparkling citrus punch that shines at parties.
• Cranberry Whiskey Sour: A tart and bright winter version of a classic sour.