The Sugar Cookie Cocktail brings the cozy comfort of holiday baking straight to your glass. This creamy drink blends vanilla vodka, Kahlua, and sugar cookie creamer to create a sweet, smooth flavor that tastes just like a fresh batch of cookies. It’s rich, festive, and perfect for dessert or a winter night by the fire. The frosted rim coated with Christmas sprinkles adds a playful touch that makes it feel extra special. Whether you’re hosting a holiday party or enjoying a quiet evening at home, this cocktail delivers warmth, sweetness, and a little nostalgic charm in every sip.

This post may include affiliate links; for details, see our disclosure policy

Tasting Notes

The Sugar Cookie Cocktail is creamy, smooth, and full of cozy sweetness. It combines vanilla vodka, coffee liqueur, and sugar cookie-flavored creamer for a dessert-like sip that tastes just like a holiday treat in liquid form. The half and half adds a rich, silky texture that balances the sweetness without feeling too heavy. The frosted, sprinkle-coated rim adds both fun and nostalgia, making it a true crowd-pleaser. Notes of vanilla, coffee, and baked sugar cookie mingle beautifully, creating a drink that’s playful yet comforting. It’s perfect for anyone who loves dessert cocktails or festive winter flavors.

Equipment and Glassware

Making this Sugar Cookie Cocktail is easy with just a few tools and a touch of creativity. You’ll need a rocks glass or short tumbler to showcase the colorful, sprinkled rim. A bar spoon is helpful for stirring the mixture evenly without over-mixing. Keep a saucer handy for rolling the frosted rim in sprinkles, and use a small spatula or butter knife to spread the vanilla frosting smoothly. Ice is key to keeping the drink cold and creamy. While you don’t need a shaker, make sure all ingredients are chilled beforehand for the best texture and taste.

Ingredients

1 oz sugar cookie-flavored coffee creamer
2 oz vanilla-flavored vodka
1 oz half and half
1 oz Kahlua
Vanilla frosting for rimming
sprinkles for rimming

Instructions

Begin by decorating the glass rim. Spread a thin layer of vanilla frosting around the rim of your glass.
Add sprinkles to a saucer, then dip the frosted rim into the sprinkles until it’s fully coated. Set the glass aside.
Fill the prepared glass with ice.
Pour in the sugar cookie-flavored coffee creamer, vanilla vodka, half and half, and Kahlua.
Stir gently to combine all ingredients.
Serve immediately and enjoy your festive, cookie-flavored cocktail!

Pro Tips

Chill your glass before rimming for better frosting adhesion.
Use coarse sprinkles—they stick better and look more festive.
Swap half and half for heavy cream if you prefer a thicker texture.
Stir gently to avoid thinning the drink too much.
For extra sweetness, drizzle caramel or chocolate syrup inside the glass before pouring.
Try vanilla bean or sugar cookie vodka for an extra boost of flavor.
Make it non-alcoholic by skipping vodka and Kahlua and using extra creamer.
Serve with a sugar cookie on the side for a fun garnish.

When to Serve

This Sugar Cookie Cocktail is perfect for winter holidays, especially Christmas gatherings, cookie exchanges, or cozy nights by the fire. Its creamy texture and dessert-like flavor make it a great after-dinner drink or a sweet treat at festive parties. The colorful rim makes it eye-catching and fun for guests, while the comforting mix of vanilla and coffee notes gives it a grown-up twist. It’s ideal for pairing with holiday desserts or sipping alongside a plate of freshly baked cookies. Whether entertaining friends or relaxing at home, this drink captures the joy of the season.

Which Liquor Brands to Choose

Vodka

Smirnoff Vanilla
Absolut Vanilia
Stolichnaya Vanil
Tito’s Handmade
Grey Goose La Vanille

Coffee Liqueur

Kahlua
Tia Maria
Mr. Black Cold Brew
Kapali

Similar Cocktails