In my years of mixing drinks, I’ve found that when the cold bites, nothing welcomes warmth like a hot cocktail. Hold a mug that warms you up from the inside, offering a cozy, comforting feeling. We’re talking about a blend of rich flavors—spicy, sweet, sometimes a bit tangy, but always heartwarming. My go-to list includes everything from the classic hot toddy to innovative twists on cider and luxurious hot chocolate cocktails. Each recipe is a testament to simplicity and warmth, perfect for braving the chill, enjoying with friends, or unwinding alone. Trust me, these picks are what your winter evenings need.
This post may include affiliate links; for details, see our disclosure policy
Hot Buttered Rum

Hot Buttered Rum is a spectacular cocktail based on a tried-and-true recipe of warm cider or hot water, a lot of melted butter, and plenty of rum to go along with it. The butter lends a velvety taste and feel to the cocktail, and the whole thing feels super festive. Make this hot cocktail on the stove with your dark rum of choice, butter, water, and plenty of warm fall spices. Don’t forget the cinnamon stick for a festive fall look!
Irish Coffee
Irish Coffee is one of the most popular and best hot cocktails you can drink. Even better, it’s super simple to make. First, you’ll need premium, high-quality hot coffee. Add Irish whiskey, brown sugar to sweeten, and top with whipped cream. You can add Bailey’s Irish Cream if you want, or add your preferred creamer if you want it creamier. I love the look of the classic Irish Coffee glass if you can find them, but your favorite mug will also do!
Hot Toddy
This old-school drink is a fanciful and excellent combination of hot water, sugar, and strong liquor. Although you can use any liquor you want, most people use Irish whiskey, scotch, or bourbon in a classic Hot Toddy. Rum also tastes good in a hot toddy. Add some citrus for a little extra flavor, and you’re good to go. I like to add a cinnamon stick and lemon wheel for a garnish!
Mint Hot Chocolate
Cozy up with the Mint Hot Chocolate, a decadent and festive drink that blends rich hot chocolate with a refreshing hint of spearmint vodka. Topped with whipped cream and colorful sprinkles, this cocktail is a perfect way to warm up your winter evenings with a touch of holiday cheer.
Rum Hot Chocolate
Warm up with a rich and creamy Rum Hot Chocolate, a cozy drink perfect for winter nights. Made with dark rum and raw cacao, this decadent treat is finished with frothy milk and chocolate sprinkles, adding a luxurious touch to each sip. It’s a festive, grown-up twist on a classic favorite.
Pecan Pie Hot Buttered Rum
The Pecan Pie Hot Buttered Rum is a rich and indulgent twist on the classic hot buttered rum. With the sweet, nutty flavor of pecan pie syrup and the warmth of spiced butter and dark rum, this cocktail is perfect for cozy winter nights or holiday gatherings, delivering comforting flavors in every sip.
Hot Spiked Caramel Apple Cider
Hot Spiked Caramel Apple Cider is a warm, comforting drink that combines the rich flavors of apple cider and apple brandy with the sweetness of caramel syrup. Topped with whipped cream and an extra drizzle of caramel, this cozy cocktail is perfect for chilly fall evenings or holiday gatherings. It’s the ultimate autumn treat, bringing together classic seasonal flavors with a delightful kick.
Apple-Brandy Hot Toddies
The Apple-Brandy Hot Toddies is a warm, soothing cocktail perfect for chilly evenings. Combining the sweet richness of honey with the tartness of lemon and the smoothness of apple brandy, this drink is enhanced by the comforting warmth of a cinnamon stick. It’s the ideal drink for cozy gatherings or relaxing by the fire.
Warm Gin Caramel
Cozy up with the Warm Gin Caramel, a delightful winter cocktail that combines the smooth warmth of gin, the citrusy kick of Cointreau, and the rich sweetness of caramel syrup. Topped with hot water and a dash of Angostura bitters, this drink is perfect for chilly evenings by the fire.
Bourbon Chai Tea
Enjoy the warm, spiced flavors of this Bourbon Chai Tea, a comforting blend of black tea, aromatic spices, almond milk, and a splash of bourbon. This cozy drink is perfect for gatherings or quiet evenings by the fire, bringing together rich chai flavors with a hint of vanilla and honeyed sweetness.
Spiked Pumpkin Spice Latte
Who doesn’t love Spiked Pumpkin Spice Lattes? You get all the warm fall flavors of the pumpkin spice with a nice jolt of vanilla vodka and Fireball. It’s an excellent, super easy cocktail to make that will certainly bring all the holiday cheer into your life. Plus, you can batch it and make it in a crockpot.
Apple Cider Mulled Wine
This recipe is excellent for a big group of people. First, warm up your cider and wine in a crockpot, then add some aromatics. Honey, cinnamon sticks, anise, cloves, and a touch of orange zest make this cider sing. You can keep it hot all night and serve it to a big group of people with individual cinnamon sticks.
Chai Tea with Bourbon
Chai with bourbon is a little more difficult to make than the others on our list, although it’s certainly worth it. If you want a shortcut, use chai tea bags instead of making the chai yourself with water, spice, vanilla, and ginger. Add bourbon to your hot tea to taste, and you’re all set to go.
Apple Cider Hot Toddy with Maple Syrup
This take on a hot toddy will warm your soul. Add the maple syrup first, then some bourbon and the apple cider mix to create this hot drink. The combination is full of fall flavors, with a sweetness from the maple syrup and a bite from the bourbon. Add a cinnamon stick as a garnish and for extra flavor!
Maple Bourbon Apple Cider
This cocktail is relatively simple to make and exceptionally delicious. All you need is a high-quality apple cider, some premium maple syrup, and whiskey. Then, add your whiskey to taste and brighten the whole thing with fresh lemon juice.
Parisian Coffee
Parisian Coffee is a highly caffeinated and alcoholic drink that gets its kick from Cointreau and Kahlua. Add some whipped cream and a bit of chocolate on top if you want to be fancy. This coffee is best made individually and served immediately.
Warm White Russian Cocktail
We all know and love cold White Russians, but warm White Russian Cocktails are delicious too. The secret ingredient is hot, fresh coffee. Then, add the other components of a White Russian; vodka, milk, and a splash of Kahlua. Whipped cream on top makes this cocktail extra special.
Warm Spiced Vanilla Cocktail
This cocktail is both heavy on the booze and exceptionally lovely and sweet, thanks to a potent combination of Baileys Irish Cream, bourbon, maple syrup, and vanilla. Add some nutmeg on top for a spicy kick to give it a beautiful fall flavor.
Hot Green Tea with Vodka
Super simple to make and warming on a cold day, Hot Green Tea with Vodka only requires a few ingredients. Take your freshly brewed green sea, add some vodka, and put honey and citrus to taste. You can even make a pot of tea and customize each glass to your guests’ preferences.
Warm Caramel Apple Cocktail
This cocktail combines two beloved fall flavors; caramel and apples. You also only need a few ingredients to tie it all together. Start with warm apple cider, then add in some dark rum and a bit of cinnamon. Top the whole thing with whip cream and a generous caramel drizzle, and you have a cocktail to celebrate.
Warm Apple Pie Cocktail
While this cocktail has a few extra ingredients, it’s worth putting together for a fancy party. Ultimately, it comes together quickly if you have spices on hand and can keep it warm in a crockpot. Hot apple cider, rum, and fall spices all combine for this yummy drink.
Spiked Apple Cider Fall Drink
Spiked Apple Cider Fall Drink is one of the best warm cocktails around, although you can also drink it cold during those warmer fall days. Spiced rum is the secret to this drink because it lends a whole new flavor to the cocktail. Lemon juice, maple syrup, and ground cinnamon all work spectacularly.
Mulled Wine
Mulled wine is a classic, warm cocktail that’s perfect for chilly evenings and festive gatherings. Dry red wine, brandy, citrus, whole cloves, cinnamon sticks, star anise, and sugar combine to make a warming winter drink that will quickly become a household favorite as the weather becomes colder. With its rich, comforting flavors and cozy warmth, it’s sure to become a new winter favorite.
Warm Old-Fashioned
A variation on the traditional cocktail that is ideal for chilly winter nights is the Warm Old Fashioned. The bourbon whiskey provides a smooth and smoky flavor that’s perfectly balanced by the sweetness of the orange slice and maraschino cherry. The aromatic bitters add a touch of bitterness that enhances the overall flavor profile of the drink. This delightful drink will undoubtedly become a new winter favorite, whether you enjoy traditional cocktails or are searching for something novel and decadent.
Gingerbread Winter Warm Up
The Gingerbread Winter Warm Up has a comforting, rich, and harmonious flavor. This sweet and somewhat bitter beverage is made with hot water, gingerbread syrup, Angostura bitters, Irish whiskey, and Kerrygold Irish Cream. The contrasting sweet and bitter notes of this drink will please anyone looking for a pleasant and cozy winter beverage.
Adult Hot Chocolate
Anyone who has a sweet craving will love the delicious and decadent Adult Hot Chocolate. Made with peppermint schnapps and hot chocolate, this drink has a perfectly balanced taste that’s both sweet and slightly bitter. Adding whipped cream and chocolate syrup to the drink makes it even more decadent and delicious. The mix of sweet and slightly bitter tastes makes for a unique and appealing flavor that will please anyone looking for a tasty and comfortable drink.
Tokyo Toddy Cocktail
The Tokyo Toddy Cocktail has a well-balanced taste that’s neither too sweet nor too bitter. Natural brown sugar’s richness pairs well with the artificial sweetness of mandarin liqueur, and the ginger adds a touch of spice to set off the sweetness. The sake in this drink adds a subtle yet complex flavor that’s reminiscent of traditional Japanese sake. Anyone searching for a distinctive and refreshing beverage will like the Tokyo Toddy beverage’s flawless combination of sweet and salty ingredients.
Sweet and Rich Hot Buttered Bourbon
If you’re in the mood for a warm, soothing drink, look no farther than the sweet and rich Hot Buttered Bourbon. Butter, cinnamon, a pinch of nutmeg, and brown sugar come together to produce a sweet and rich flavor in this cocktail, making it ideal for sipping on chilly winter evenings. The Sweet and Rich Hot Buttered Bourbon is one of the best warm cocktails you can make at home.
Spiced Cranberry Hot Toddy
As far as hot winter cocktails go, hot toddies are one of the most well-known. This recipe adds something extra to the classic, switching up standard ingredients for the bright, tart flavor of cranberries. Maple syrup adds a sweetness that pairs perfectly with the sweeter tones of bourbon used in this toddy. We love a brown sugar rim as well!
Spiked Hot Chocolate Whiskey with Marshmallows
Enhance your favorite wintertime treat with this spiked hot chocolate recipe. Create rich and creamy chocolate milk using dark chocolate sauce and heavy cream, which acts as the cocktail’s base. Skip the hot chocolate and make this one from scratch! Shake with your favorite Irish whiskey, and serve for a cool drink or for a hot one, slowly warm the mixture on the stove.