Brian Nagele
Thanksgiving rum cocktails bring a warm and relaxed feel to the holiday, making them a great choice for guests who enjoy rich, smooth drinks with seasonal flavor. Rum pairs well with many fall ingredients such as apple, cranberry, pumpkin, and warm spices, giving you plenty of options to serve before dinner or during dessert. These cocktails can be light and fruity or deep and cozy, depending on what you prefer. They add color, comfort, and a touch of fun to any gathering. Whether you are hosting a big meal or keeping things small, rum cocktails help set a welcoming and festive tone.
Pumpkin Pie Martini
The Pumpkin Pie Martini is a fall favorite that delivers all the flavors of the season in a single glass. This rich and creamy cocktail starts with salted caramel vodka, RumChata, and pumpkin cream liqueur, giving it a smooth and sweet base. Pumpkin pie purée and cinnamon syrup add warmth and spice, creating a taste that feels cozy and comforting.
The glass is rimmed with caramel and brown sugar, then topped with whipped cream and a sprinkle of cinnamon for a festive finish. Perfect for Thanksgiving, Halloween, or autumn parties, this martini is like dessert with a spirited twist.
Autumn Harvest Rum Punch
The Autumn Harvest Rum Punch is a colorful and flavorful drink that celebrates the best tastes of the season. It combines crisp apple cider, tart cranberry juice, and mellow pear juice with the warmth of spiced rum for a balanced mix of sweet, tart, and spiced notes.
Just before serving, sparkling white wine is added to give the punch a light and refreshing finish. Fresh fruits and cinnamon sticks make the presentation festive and inviting, turning this drink into a centerpiece for any table. Ideal for holiday parties or casual gatherings, it is a true crowd-pleaser for autumn.
Spiced Velvet
The Spiced Velvet is a creamy autumn-inspired cocktail that blends warm spices with smooth, dessert-like flavors. Spiced rum provides a bold, aromatic base, while RumChata (or another cinnamon cream liqueur) adds a silky, cinnamon-forward sweetness.
Vanilla almond milk keeps the drink light yet rich, and pumpkin puree brings seasonal flair with just the right hint of warmth. Finished with a sprinkle of pumpkin pie spice, this cocktail is festive, comforting, and indulgent in the best way. Served in a martini glass, it’s the perfect balance of creamy texture and fall spice.
Thanksgiving Rum Punch
The Thanksgiving Rum Punch is a warm, spiced, and festive drink that brings the cozy flavors of the season to your glass. It combines apple cider, cranberry juice, and spiced rum for a rich and flavorful base, while ginger beer adds a crisp, bubbly finish.
Honey, cinnamon sticks, and cloves infuse the punch with sweetness and comforting spice, creating the perfect balance of flavors. Fresh lemon slices and rosemary sprigs give it a bright and aromatic touch. Served over ice, this punch is easy to make in large batches, making it ideal for Thanksgiving gatherings and holiday celebrations with family and friends.
Spiced Apple Tiki Smash
The Spiced Apple Tiki Smash is a fun seasonal cocktail that combines tropical style with the comforting flavors of fall. Spiced rum creates a warm base that pairs beautifully with the crisp sweetness of apple cider and the bright taste of pineapple juice.
Allspice dram and falernum add rich layers of spice, bringing depth and complexity that make each sip interesting. The result is a tiki-inspired drink with a festive autumn twist, blending fruity notes with cozy spice. Perfect for fall gatherings, this cocktail is a great way to enjoy tropical flavors while still keeping the spirit of the season.
Pecan Pie Hot Buttered Rum
The Pecan Pie Hot Buttered Rum is a seasonal twist on the classic that brings the comfort of dessert flavors into a warm winter drink. Dark rum creates a smooth, rich base, while spiced butter adds depth and a cozy aroma.
Pecan pie syrup blends in sweetness with a nutty flavor that makes this cocktail stand out from the traditional version. Served hot, it is topped with a gentle froth that feels comforting with every sip. Perfect for holiday gatherings, festive dinners, or a quiet evening by the fire, this drink combines warmth, sweetness, and spice in a satisfying way.
Rum Harvest Cocktail
The Rum Harvest Cocktail is a refreshing drink that highlights the bold and comforting flavors of fall. Spiced rum brings warmth and depth, balanced by the tart flavor of cranberry juice and the bright citrus notes of lime.
A splash of Coke on top adds a touch of sweetness and fizz, tying everything together in a smooth, easy-to-drink cocktail. The mix of fruity, spiced, and citrus flavors makes it a versatile choice for gatherings of any kind. Whether you are hosting a holiday party or relaxing on a cool autumn evening, this cocktail is both simple and satisfying.
Caramel Apple & Spiced Rum Cocktail
The Caramel Apple & Spiced Rum Cocktail is a drink that brings together the most comforting flavors of fall in every sip. Sweet caramel blends smoothly with crisp apple cider, creating a balance of richness and freshness.
Spiced rum adds warmth and depth, giving the cocktail a cozy character that fits perfectly with the season. The combination of sweet, spiced, and fruity flavors makes this drink both inviting and satisfying. Ideal for autumn evenings, holiday gatherings, or simply relaxing by the fire, this cocktail is a festive choice that captures the feeling of fall in a glass.
Fall in Paradise
Fall in Paradise is a seasonal cocktail that blends the richness of Demerara rum with the crisp taste of apple cider and the tropical sweetness of pineapple juice. A touch of allspice dram adds warm spice, while lime juice balances the drink with refreshing acidity.
Finished with bitters for depth, this cocktail is layered, flavorful, and perfect for autumn gatherings. Garnished with cherries and pineapple, it bridges the cozy flavors of fall with the brightness of the tropics, making it a unique drink that feels equally suited for a cool evening or a festive celebration.
Autumn Spiced Rum Cider Cocktail
The Autumn Spiced Rum Cider is a cocktail that combines the best flavors of fall in one warm and comforting drink. Smooth spiced rum pairs beautifully with sweet apple cider, while hard cider adds a crisp and refreshing edge.
A dash of lemon bitters brings just the right amount of brightness, giving the drink balance and keeping it from feeling too heavy. The mix of sweet, spiced, and citrus notes makes this cocktail perfect for chilly evenings, autumn dinners, or festive gatherings. Easy to prepare and full of flavor, it is a seasonal favorite that feels cozy and inviting.
Autumn Rum Old Fashioned
The Autumn Rum Old Fashioned is a seasonal take on a timeless cocktail, bringing warmth and comfort to cool fall evenings. Instead of whiskey, this version uses aged rum, which adds depth with smooth and rich flavor.
Apple cider syrup gives the drink a gentle sweetness that pairs perfectly with the rum, while Angostura bitters add layers of spice and aroma. An orange twist on top brightens the drink and ties the flavors together. This cocktail is simple yet full of character, making it a great choice for autumn gatherings, holiday dinners, or a quiet evening by the fire.
Autumn Spiced Rum Punch
The Autumn Spiced Rum Punch is a cocktail that captures the flavors of the season in a way that feels festive and comforting. It starts with smooth spiced rum, which brings warmth and depth, then combines it with a mix of fruit juices that add sweetness and brightness.
Fresh fruits like apples, oranges, and cranberries not only enhance the flavor but also make the punch colorful and inviting. Served in a large bowl or pitcher, it is easy to prepare for gatherings and perfect for sharing. This punch is a seasonal favorite for parties, holiday celebrations, or cozy fall evenings.
Honeycrisp Apple Cider Rum Punch
The Honeycrisp Apple Cider Rum Punch is a seasonal favorite that blends crisp fruit flavors with the comforting warmth of rum. Fresh Honeycrisp apple cider brings natural sweetness, while orange juice adds a bright citrus note that keeps the drink lively.
The smoothness of rum ties the flavors together, and a touch of cinnamon adds gentle spice that feels perfect for autumn. Garnished with slices of fresh apples, oranges, or even cranberries, this punch is colorful and festive. Easy to make in a large pitcher or bowl, it is an ideal choice for fall gatherings, parties, or cozy evenings with friends.
Apple Cider Cable Car Cocktail
The Apple Cider Cable Car Cocktail is a flavorful seasonal version of the classic Cable Car that highlights the best tastes of autumn. It begins with aged or spiced rum, bringing warmth and depth, and pairs it with the crisp, tangy character of apple cider.
Cointreau adds a smooth orange note, while fresh lemon juice brightens the drink with a refreshing touch of citrus. The result is a cocktail that feels both cozy and lively, perfect for sharing at fall gatherings, dinner parties, or casual evenings at home. This drink is a wonderful way to enjoy cider in a new form.
Apple Cider Mojito
The Apple Cider Mojito is a refreshing twist on the classic mojito, designed for those early autumn afternoons when the air is crisp but still carries a bit of summer warmth. This drink combines the light, clean taste of white rum with the sweetness of apple cider, balanced by fresh lime juice and a touch of simple syrup.
Club soda adds sparkle, making the cocktail lively and refreshing. Quick to prepare in just a few minutes, it requires only a bar spoon and muddler. The Apple Cider Mojito is a seasonal favorite that is easy, bright, and perfect for sharing.
Spiced Apple Prosecco
The Spiced Apple Prosecco is a festive cocktail that brings together the cozy flavors of fall with the light sparkle of bubbly wine. It begins with spiced rum, which adds warmth and depth, paired with crisp apple cider for natural sweetness.
Topped with a pour of Prosecco, the drink becomes lively and refreshing, offering a balance of rich flavor and bright fizz. This cocktail is easy to prepare, yet it feels special enough for holiday gatherings, fall parties, or a quiet evening at home. With its blend of spice, fruit, and bubbles, it is a seasonal favorite worth sharing.
Apple Maple Dark and Stormy
The Apple Maple Dark and Stormy is a flavorful fall version of the classic cocktail, bringing together rich, sweet, and spicy notes in every sip. Dark rum creates a bold base with smooth depth, while maple syrup adds a touch of sweetness that feels comforting and warm.
Apple juice or cider brightens the drink with crisp, fruity flavor that balances the richness. Spicy ginger beer on top gives it fizz and a kick of heat, making the cocktail lively and refreshing. Garnished with a fresh apple slice, this drink is an inviting choice for cozy autumn nights or seasonal gatherings.
Pumpkin Piña Colada
The Pumpkin Piña Colada is a fun mix of fall flavor and tropical style, giving you a drink that feels seasonal and sunny at the same time. It keeps the classic blend of pineapple juice and coconut cream, which creates a smooth, creamy base with a bright fruity taste.
Pumpkin purée adds warmth and a cozy fall touch, while a pinch of cinnamon brings gentle spice. Rum gives the drink a steady, rich finish without making it too heavy. Topped with whipped cream, nutmeg, and a pineapple wedge, this cocktail is great for autumn parties or quiet nights when you want something comforting and cheerful.
Hot Apple Buttered Rum
The Hot Apple Buttered Rum is a seasonal cocktail that combines rich apple flavor with the warmth of spiced rum and sweet spices. Apple butter gives the drink a smooth, fruity base, while dark spiced rum adds depth and gentle heat.
A touch of brown sugar blends in to create extra sweetness, making each sip cozy and satisfying. Served steaming hot and finished with slices of fresh apple and a cinnamon stick, it looks just as inviting as it tastes. This drink is perfect for fall or winter nights, whether you are sharing it at a holiday gathering or enjoying it by the fire.
Caramel Hot Toddy
The Caramel Hot Toddy is a warm and soothing cocktail that brings together the bold flavor of dark rum, the brightness of lemon, and the sweet richness of caramel. Hot tea forms the base, giving the drink a smooth and comforting feel, while the caramel syrup adds depth and a dessert-like quality that sets it apart from the traditional version.
The combination of tart citrus, gentle sweetness, and spiced rum creates a balance that is both relaxing and flavorful. Perfect for chilly nights, quiet evenings, or seasonal gatherings, this hot toddy is a cozy twist on a timeless favorite.
Brandy-Pecan Flip
The Brandy-Pecan Flip is a smooth and creamy cocktail that brings together comforting fall flavors in one cozy drink. Pecan milk gives it a soft, nutty base, while brandy adds gentle warmth and depth. A small amount of rum rounds out the flavor, creating a mix that feels full and balanced without being too heavy.
Simple syrup adds light sweetness, and the whole egg gives the drink a thicker, cream-style texture that makes each sip feel relaxing and steady. A light sprinkle of nutmeg on top adds aroma and a touch of spice. This cocktail is great for quiet evenings or holiday gatherings.
Pumpkin Spice Hot Buttered Rum
The Pumpkin Spice Hot Buttered Rum is a warm and relaxing drink that fits perfectly into cooler nights during fall and winter. It blends dark rum with a spiced butter mixture that melts into the drink, giving it a smooth and comforting feel. A small amount of pumpkin adds seasonal flavor without making it too sweet.
As the mixture warms, the spices come forward and create a cozy aroma that fills the room. Topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of pumpkin pie sauce, this drink is rich, soothing, and great for quiet evenings or holiday gatherings with friends and family.
Spiced Maple Rum Cocktail
The Spiced Maple Rum Cocktail is a warm and comforting drink that brings together cozy fall flavors in a smooth and balanced way. Dark spiced rum gives it depth and gentle heat, while real maple syrup adds natural sweetness that feels rich without being heavy. A squeeze of lemon brightens the drink and keeps the flavors lively.
The mix of sweet, tart, and lightly spiced notes makes this cocktail easy to enjoy on cool evenings or during autumn get-togethers with friends. It is simple to make, pleasing to sip, and a great choice for anyone who enjoys relaxed seasonal drinks.
Rum and Apple Juice
The Rum and Apple Juice cocktail is a simple yet flavorful drink that highlights the natural sweetness of apple juice paired with the warming spice of rum. Easy to make with just two main ingredients, it’s refreshing while still carrying a cozy, autumn-inspired character.
Served over ice and stirred with a cinnamon stick, it develops a subtle spiced note that complements the fruitiness of the apple. Garnished with fresh apple slices, this cocktail is both quick to prepare and visually appealing perfect for casual sipping, seasonal gatherings, or when you want a straightforward drink with comforting flavors.
