Paul Kushner
I’m excited to share my favorite Christmas rum cocktails, perfect for holiday gatherings. These drinks capture the essence of the season, blending rum’s warm spice with festive flavors. From the comforting Hot Buttered Rum to innovative twists on traditional favorites, each recipe is a hit at parties. They’re not only delicious but also embody the Christmas spirit in every sip. Trust me, your guests will love them. I recommend checking out the full roundup to find your holiday drink highlight.
This post may include affiliate links; for details, see our disclosure policy
1
mybartender.com
Olive Garden Italian Rum Punch
The Olive Garden Italian Rum Punch is a sweet and tangy cocktail that blends the bold flavors of Bacardi Superior rum with the nutty sweetness of amaretto and the fruity richness of strawberry-passion syrup. Combined with sour mix, this punch offers a perfect balance of sweet and tart, ideal for a refreshing drink.
View Recipe
2
mybartender.com
Pecan Pie Hot Buttered Rum
The Pecan Pie Hot Buttered Rum is a rich and indulgent twist on the classic hot buttered rum. With the sweet, nutty flavor of pecan pie syrup and the warmth of spiced butter and dark rum, this cocktail is perfect for cozy winter nights or holiday gatherings, delivering comforting flavors in every sip.
View Recipe
3
mybartender.com
Caramel Hot Toddy
The Caramel Hot Toddy is a cozy and soothing cocktail that combines the warmth of dark rum with the tartness of lemon juice and the sweet richness of caramel syrup. Infused with hot tea, this drink is perfect for chilly evenings or when you want to relax with a comforting, flavorful beverage. The caramel adds a decadent twist to the classic hot toddy, making it both delicious and warming.
View Recipe
4
mybartender.com
Hot Apple Buttered Rum
The Hot Apple Buttered Rum is a cozy, spiced drink perfect for chilly nights. This cocktail blends rich apple flavors with dark spiced rum, apple butter, and a touch of brown sugar, creating a sweet and warming beverage. Garnished with apple slices and cinnamon sticks, it’s a perfect fall or winter treat.
View Recipe
5
mybartender.com
Cuban Peach
The Cuban Peach is a tropical and refreshing blend that combines the sweetness of ripe peaches with the crisp, smooth flavor of white rum. Enhanced with peach schnapps and a touch of lime juice, this cocktail is perfect for sipping on a warm day. Garnished with a peach wedge and fresh mint, it’s a delightful taste of the tropics.
View Recipe
6
mybartender.com
Peach Daiquiri
The Peach Daiquiri is a refreshing and fruity twist on the classic daiquiri, blending the smoothness of white rum with the sweet and tangy flavors of peach schnapps, lime juice, and orange juice. This cocktail is perfect for summer, offering a vibrant and delicious way to cool off on a warm day.
View Recipe
7
mybartender.com
Rum Harvest Cocktail
The Rum Harvest Cocktail is a simple yet refreshing drink that combines the warm spices of rum with the tartness of cranberry juice and the bright citrus notes of lime. Topped with a splash of Coke, this cocktail offers a perfect balance of flavors, making it a delightful choice for any fall gathering.
View Recipe
8
mybartender.com
Apple Cider Punch
Apple Cider Punch is a delightful and refreshing beverage that combines the flavors of apple, citrus, and spices. Perfect for gatherings and celebrations, this punch can be made with or without rum, making it a versatile drink for any occasion.
View Recipe
9
mybartender.com
Hot Honey Rum Punch
The Hot Honey Rum Punch cocktail is a bold and fiery drink that combines the sweetness of local honey with the intense heat of habanero peppers. Balanced with light rum and fresh lemon juice, this cocktail is perfect for those who love a bit of spice in their drinks.
View Recipe
10
mybartender.com
Coconut Blackberry Mojito
The Coconut Blackberry Mojito is a tropical twist on the classic mojito. Combining fresh blackberries, mint, white rum, and creamy coconut, this cocktail is rich, refreshing, and beautifully balanced. Finished with a sugar lime rim and topped with soda water, it’s the perfect drink for any tropical occasion.
View Recipe
11
mybartender.com
Cocoa Berry Rum Punch
The Cocoa Berry Rum Punch is a rich and indulgent cocktail that combines the sweet, creamy flavors of Chocolate Strawberry Liqueur with the depth of dark rum and a touch of coconut. Garnished with a chocolate-covered strawberry, this drink is a decadent treat, perfect for special occasions or dessert cocktails.
View Recipe
12
mybartender.com
Santa’s Pomegranate Punch
Celebrate the season with a Santa’s Pomegranate Punch that combines the warmth of rum with the refreshing taste of pomegranate and lime. This easy-to-make drink brings a festive red hue and is beautifully garnished with pomegranate arils and a lime wheel, making it a visually stunning addition to any holiday gathering.
View Recipe
13
mybartender.com
Yuletide Spice
Celebrate the season with the Yuletide Spice cocktail, a delightful blend of spiced rum, Amaro Amorino, and fresh citrus. With warm notes from cinnamon and ginger simple syrups and a hint of aromatic bitters, this cocktail is festive and full of holiday flavor, perfect for any winter gathering.
View Recipe
14
mybartender.com
Coconut Rum Punch
Transport yourself to a tropical paradise with this Coconut Rum Punch. A refreshing mix of rum, pineapple juice, and rich coconut cream, finished with a splash of grenadine, it’s the perfect drink for a summer party or a beach-inspired escape.
View Recipe
15
mybartender.com
Blue Christmas Cocktail
The Blue Christmas Cocktail is a festive and tropical-inspired holiday drink. With pineapple juice, coconut cream, and a touch of Blue Curaçao, this cocktail is smooth, creamy, and beautifully blue. The optional honey and shredded coconut rim add a snowy effect, making it a perfect cocktail for winter celebrations.
View Recipe
16
mybartender.com
Chocolate Hot Buttered Rum
Chocolate Hot Buttered Rum is a delightful, warm beverage perfect for chilly evenings. This rich and creamy drink combines the sweet flavors of chocolate with the spicy kick of rum. It’s a unique twist on the traditional hot buttered rum, offering a cozy and indulgent experience. This recipe is easy to follow, making it a great choice for anyone wanting to enjoy a special, homemade treat.
View Recipe
17
mybartender.com
Honeycrisp Apple Cider Rum Punch
The Honeycrisp Apple Cider Rum Punch is a refreshing and cozy drink that’s perfect for fall gatherings. Combining the natural sweetness of Honeycrisp apple cider with the bright notes of orange juice and the warmth of rum, this punch is spiced with cinnamon and garnished with fresh fruit slices, making it a delightful treat for any occasion.
View Recipe
18
mybartender.com
Apple Maple Dark and Stormy
The Apple Maple Dark and Stormy is a seasonal twist on the classic cocktail, combining the rich depth of dark rum with the sweetness of maple syrup and the crisp flavor of apple juice or cider. Topped with spicy ginger beer and garnished with a slice of apple, this cocktail is perfect for cozy nights.
View Recipe
19
mybartender.com
Spiced Rum Milk Punch
Close your eyes and imagine a creamy, dreamy blend of milk infused with aromatic spices like nutmeg and cinnamon. Now add a splash of that smooth spiced rum – it's like a warm hug from the holidays. Whether you enjoy it over ice to chill out after a bustling day or warm it up for those cozy, fireside moments, it's the perfect way to wind down and toast to the season.
View Recipe
20
Hot Buttered Rum
Hot Buttered Rum is one of the easiest cocktails to make around the holidays. It’s easy to adjust this recipe to keep a pot on the stove, ready to welcome guests in from the cold. All you need is spiced rum, dark brown sugar, cinnamon, and boiling water. As a bonus, it’s highly aromatic. The smell of cinnamon and other wintry spices will waft through your home. You could even add a scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side for a real treat.
View Recipe
21
mybartender.com
White Christmas Mojito
Dreaming of a white Christmas? This festive White Christmas Mojito brings holiday vibes with creamy coconut, refreshing mint, and a hint of lime. It’s the perfect holiday cocktail to brighten up any gathering, with pomegranate arils for a touch of seasonal color and sparkle.
View Recipe
22
mybartender.com
Christmas Rum Cocktail
Celebrate the season with a Christmas Rum Cocktail, a warming blend of spiced rum, cranberry juice, and a hint of lemon, topped with ginger beer for a festive fizz. This cocktail is simple, refreshing, and perfect for holiday gatherings, with a garnish of rosemary and lemon for an extra seasonal touch.
View Recipe
23
mybartender.com
Rum Hot Chocolate
Warm up with a rich and creamy Rum Hot Chocolate, a cozy drink perfect for winter nights. Made with dark rum and raw cacao, this decadent treat is finished with frothy milk and chocolate sprinkles, adding a luxurious touch to each sip. It’s a festive, grown-up twist on a classic favorite.
View Recipe
24
mybartender.com
Christmas Spiced Rum Sour
The Christmas Spiced Rum Sour is a cozy twist on the classic sour, blending spiced rum, fresh lemon juice, and a touch of sweetness. Garnished with an orange slice and a cherry, this cocktail is simple yet festive—perfect for holiday gatherings and winter evenings.
View Recipe
25
mybartender.com
Tom & Jerry Cocktail
Ah, here comes the grandpa of holiday drinks! This traditional Christmas drink mixes up a rich, spicy batter with rum—super comforting and indulgent. It's the liquid equivalent of being wrapped up in a cozy blanket while watching snowflakes dance outside. Grab a mug, gather your favorite people around, and enjoy it during a festive game night or while reminiscing about good old times. This is a great choice to make in large batch format for a holiday party.
View Recipe
26
Berry Cherry Holiday
The Berry Cherry Holiday cocktail is a festive blend of rum, fresh blackberries, cherry jam, and a hint of orange, all topped with sparkling water for a refreshing twist. Garnished with sage, maraschino cherries, and blackberries, this drink brings a delightful mix of flavors and a touch of elegance to your holiday celebrations. Inspired by garnishyourglass.
View Recipe
27
Elf Mojito
The Elf Mojito is a vibrant and refreshing cocktail, perfect for spreading holiday cheer. Combining the classic flavors of mint and lime with a sweet twist of midori, this fizzy drink is topped with soda water and garnished with a lime wheel and mint leaf for a festive touch.
View Recipe
28
Holiday Mai Tai
The Holiday Mai Tai is a festive twist on the tropical classic, blending rum with the sweet and tangy flavors of pomegranate, pineapple, and lime. Orgeat and aromatic bitters add depth and complexity, making this vibrant cocktail perfect for celebrating the holiday season with a tropical flair.
View Recipe
29
Jolly Spiced Rum
The Jolly Spiced Rum cocktail is a festive blend of spiced rum, tart cranberry juice, and a touch of cinnamon, topped with refreshing ginger beer. Perfect for holiday celebrations, this drink is beautifully garnished with sugared cranberries and a rosemary sprig, bringing a touch of snowy magic to your glass.
View Recipe
30
Jack Frost Winter Cocktail
This frosty blue cocktail is the perfect winter wonderland in a glass! With a blend of tropical pineapple, creamy coconut, and a hint of rum, the Jack Frost Winter Cocktail delivers a refreshing, festive twist. Rimmed with snowy coconut flakes, it’s a drink that captures the holiday spirit with every sip.
View Recipe
31
Cinnamon Pear and Rum Cocktail
This Cinnamon Pear and Rum Cocktail is a warm and inviting drink that combines sweet pear nectar, rich dark rum, and a hint of vanilla and cinnamon. Perfect for cozy evenings or holiday gatherings, it’s garnished with fresh pear slices for an elegant seasonal touch.
View Recipe
32
Rum and Cherry Christmas Cocktail
This Rum and Cherry Christmas Cocktail is a delightful mix of rich rum, cherry liqueur, and sweet Amarena syrup, balanced with a splash of lemon juice for a festive twist. Topped with a garnish of cherries, it’s a beautifully crafted holiday drink perfect for celebrating the season.
View Recipe
33
thepurplepumpkinblog.co.uk
Naughty Elf Cocktail
Just like pirates, naughty elves prefer rum! This drink combines spiced rum with cranberry juice, grapefruit juice, and a couple of specialty liqueurs, so it’s simple to make. The recipe link includes instructions to make a fun rim for the glass. While it isn’t necessary, it will make your guests feel more festive!
View Recipe
34
womanandhome.com
Rum and Ginger Christmas Cocktail
While this cocktail is a little complicated, it’s worth it for the sophisticated, delicious, spicy, and warm result for your holiday get-together. This rum and ginger cocktail calls for a specific brand of golden rum and combines ginger wine, ginger beer, and fresh ginger, in addition to other ingredients.
View Recipe
35
www.farmwifefeeds.com
Gingerbread Baileys Holiday Cocktail
Get ready for a gingerbread party in your mouth! Baileys cuddles up with gingerbread flavors and a dash of rum—dessert in a glass, seriously! It’s like your favorite holiday cookie got transformed into a smooth, creamy sipper. Share this delight with friends at a chill holiday hangout or keep it all to yourself as a sweet treat after a long day of gift shopping.
View Recipe
36
wellplated.com
Christmas Punch
This delicious Christmas punch is festive, sparkly, easy to make, and meant to provide for a crowd. It’s the perfect party punch! Besides dark rum, you’ll need sparkling wine, cranberry juice, and a few other simple ingredients. Have fun with the garnish: you can use red cranberries, green rosemary “trees,” or other edible items.
View Recipe
37
eatliveescape.com
Rum and Cherry Brandy Christmas Cocktail
Cherries have a deep sweetness, and this cocktail brings it out to perfectly complement the alcohol in the rum. It uses cherry brandy liqueur and amarena syrup. While those are specialty ingredients, you only need the rum (preferably XO), lemon juice, and ice.
View Recipe
38
www.slumberandscones.com
Cinnamon, Pear, and Rum Cocktail with Vanilla
Imagine a deliciously fragrant blend of pear, cozy cinnamon, a touch of rum, and a hint of vanilla—pure winter magic! It's the kind of drink that warms you up from the inside out. Sip it leisurely during a laid-back evening with your favorite tunes playing in the background, maybe paired with a cheese board or some fancy appetizers.
View Recipe
39
www.therecipewench.com
Coconut Rum Holiday Cocktail
If you want a little taste of the tropics, try this Coconut Rum Cocktail. Thanks to fresh mint and simple syrup, it’s reminiscent of a mojito, and milk gives it a wintry color, especially if you add frozen cranberries to your ice cubes.
View Recipe
40
www.paleoscaleo.com
Snowblower Holiday Cocktail
The Snowblower is a delicious drink, and it's one of the most easy-to-make cocktail recipes. You only need spiced apple cider, cranberry juice, and dark rum. The dark rum adds complexity to balance the sweetness of the apple cider and cranberry, and it'll keep you warm in the cold winter months. I like to add cinnamon sticks and fresh cranberries as festive garnishes. The best part of this cocktail is that it's great whether it's served warm or cold.
View Recipe
Please drink responsibly, be fully accountable with your alcohol consumption, and show others respect.
